Healing Your Sukkos Stress: We Want Your Heart More than Your Food - Women's Sukkos Class

Before you begin

Why does the Mishnah say that whoever missed Simchas Beis HaShoevah never saw joy at all, and what does drawing water have to do with it?

The claim. The Mishnah says one who never saw Simchas Beis HaShoevah never saw simcha, one who never saw Yerushalayim never saw a beautiful city, one who never saw the Beis Hamikdash never saw a magnificent building. All stated in the negative. This is strange, since every other joy in the world still counts as joy. Something bigger than a great party is being described.

The mechanism. Water was drawn at the Shiloach before dawn and poured on the mizbeach, preceded by all-night dancing. Rashi traces this to creation: on day two the waters split, upper and lower, and the only day without כי טוב. The lower waters wept, אנן בעינן למהוי קדם מלכא, comforted only by salt and by the water libation of Sukkos.

The inner meaning. That split is not about oceans; it is the essential split inside every person, the source of nearly all anxiety. Day one is called יום אחד, not ראשון, because before the split there was one source of life, one definition of bliss. After the split, two competing definitions compete: the ego's low-hanging fruit—possessions, validation, even religion used to fill guilt—versus channeling Elokim chaim.

The turn. Yonah ben Amittai, an ordinary oleh regel, entered Simchas Beis HaShoevah and ruach hakodesh rested on him, for רוח הקודש rests only on a joyous heart. His name means dove, also deception, because the soul is easily duped once bound to a body. At the water-drawing he saw his own separation was never final, only material for return.

Where it lands. Only when the lower water is carried back to its source, while still honored as lower water, is any other joy possible; without that, every simcha is straining to fill a wound. Choosing life, ובחרת בחיים, means choosing the living part in everything. Begin each morning sitting with the neshamah, present over perfect, so the heart's own Simchas Beis HaShoevah lifts every other joy into itself.

The Water That Cried: The Secret of Simchas Beis Hashoevah

The Elusiveness of Joy

One of the hardest things to attain in life is simcha. Joy is elusive. What exactly is joy? What makes a person happy? Why are some people happier and others less happy? What is the secret of joy? There is a book by Dennis Prager titled Happiness Is a Serious Problem, and I once heard from him how he arrived at the title. He was invited by Rabbi Shlomo Schwartzie of Chabad of UCLA, many years ago, to speak to the students. The topic was happiness. He asked, what do you want me to say? And the answer came back: happiness is a serious problem. He said, that's the lecture. And that became the book.

Sukkos is defined in our davening as זמן שמחתנו. Joy, of course, is a mitzvah all year round — עבדו את ה' בשמחה,1 serve Hashem with joy. And when do you serve Hashem? Twenty-four hours a day, seven days a week. So simcha is really a mitzvah 24/7. Yet like everything in Yiddishkeit, there are days of the year that are highlighted, days that zoom into a particular theme even though the theme belongs to the whole year. Rosh Hashanah, Yom Kippur, Pesach, Shavuos — these are not one-time events. They are happening all year. It is only that we take certain days to focus with a heightened awareness. It is like a birthday or an anniversary. You should celebrate your birthday every day of the year — I hope you do. The fact that you were born is a celebration every day. We simply take the time to zoom in.

So Sukkos is the time focused particularly on simcha. But what is the nature of this joy? You might say that the previous days were days of pressure, days of awe, of intensity, and when a person finally releases the tension, he can breathe again. But that is a very limited form of joy — joy purely by contrast. Worse, it would mean that Sukkos is essentially "thank God Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur are over," which is strange. There is something far deeper here.

"He Never Saw Joy in His Life"

The Mishnah in the fifth chapter of Sukkah, and the Gemara on daf nun-aleph, page fifty-one, amud beis, teaches: תנו רבנן, מי שלא ראה שמחת בית השואבה לא ראה שמחה מימיו.2 One who did not see the celebration of Beis HaShoevah, the place of the drawing of the water, never saw joy in his entire life.

Quite a statement. It is the way people speak dramatically — if you weren't at this wedding, you never saw a wedding; if you didn't see this smorgasbord, you never saw a smorgasbord. But people exaggerate. Our sages are very, very particular, and this comes from the Mishnah, where every single word is precise. Somebody who did not see Simchas Beis HaShoevah never saw simcha in his entire life. How can that be? They were never at a joyous occasion? They never saw a joyous occasion?

And he is not finished. מי שלא ראה ירושלים בתפארתה לא ראה כרך נחמד מעולם — one who did not see Jerusalem in its glory never in his life saw a beautiful city anywhere in the world. מי שלא ראה בית המקדש בבניינו לא ראה בנין מפואר מעולם — one who did not see the Beis Hamikdash in its fully constructed state never saw a magnificent structure, ever.

Three things, and three questions. First, why are all three stated in the negative? He could easily have said it in the positive: Simchas Beis HaShoevah was the greatest joy in the world; the Beis Hamikdash was the most beautiful structure ever built. Why say instead that if you didn't see it, you never saw anything? Second, the order is strange. He begins with Simchas Beis HaShoevah, which took place inside the Beis Hamikdash, then moves out to Yerushalayim, and then comes back in to the Beis Hamikdash. Either go from the outside in — Yerushalayim, Beis Hamikdash, Simchas Beis HaShoevah — or from the inside out. Why this order?

What Actually Happened at the Drawing of the Water

Technically, what was Simchas Beis HaShoevah? The Torah speaks of drawing water בששון, with joy, the phrase we say in Havdalah. We have a tradition, a halacha l'Moshe miSinai, that on Sukkos there is a special mitzvah of nisuch hamayim, the pouring of the water. Every single morning of Sukkos, before dawn, a whole procession would go down to the Shiloach Spring. If you have ever been to Mei HaShiloach — I had the zechus to dip there in the mikvah — you know it is an extraordinary place. That is literally the spring from which they drew the water for this experience of Sukkos.

Remember, Sukkos was one of the three times a year of aliyah l'regel, when Jews from all over the land and all over the world would come to the Holy Temple in Yerushalayim. There were enormous crowds. Every morning that procession would descend to the spring, draw the water, and bring it back up — and you had to go up, as you can still see today climbing to the Har Habayis. They blew trumpets and shofar. In the morning, together with the korban tamid, wine was poured on the mizbeach every day of the year; on Sukkos there was an additional mitzvah to pour the water they had just drawn.

And as a preparation for this mitzvah, they danced all night. That is why it is called Simchas Beis HaShoevah — שואבה in Hebrew means drawing, collecting. A שואב מים is a water-drawer. It was the celebration of the place of the drawing of the water. Not only did they dance; they lit up the entire Har Habayis, and it is said that a woman in Yerushalayim could sort her wheat from pebbles by the light of the menorahs kindled on the night of Beis HaShoevah. The greatest sages juggled torches of fire. Men, women and children were there, dancing, singing, watching. Every single night of Sukkos. And in the morning they stopped the dancing, poured the water, and moved on with the day.

On this the Mishnah says: if you didn't see this simcha, you never saw simcha in your life.

Yonah's Prophecy Began at the Water-Drawing

Something else is fascinating here. Yesterday, on Yom Kippur, we read Maftir Yonah at Mincha — the highlight of the year — the story of the prophet who tried to run away from Hashem. Hashem tells him to go to Nineveh and prophesy about their corruption and their need to repent. Yonah refuses, boards a ship at Yaffo bound for Tarshish, and decides he is escaping his destiny. There is chaos and a tempest at sea, they throw him overboard, he is swallowed by a great fish, he prays, he is spat out, and he ultimately makes his way to Nineveh.

Chazal saw a deep connection between Yonah and Sukkos. The Talmud Yerushalmi in the fifth chapter of Sukkah teaches: אמר רבי יהושע בן לוי, למה נקרא שמה בית שואבה? שמשם שואבים רוח הקודש.3 Why is it called Beis HaShoevah? Because from there they drew not only water but ruach hakodesh, divine inspiration. And then: יונה בן אמיתי מעולי רגלים היה, ונכנס לשמחת בית השואבה, ושרת עליו רוח הקודש. Yonah ben Amittai — whose sefer we read on Yom Kippur — was one of the ordinary Jews who went up to Yerushalayim for the festival. He walked into the celebration of Beis HaShoevah, and there the spirit of prophecy rested upon him. ללמדך שאין רוח הקודש שורה אלא על לב שמח — to teach you that divine inspiration rests only on a joyous heart.

When a person is anxious and stressed — which is normal, utterly normal — it is very difficult to experience your own flow. I become uptight, I become defensive, my nervous system is on alert, the amygdala is frightened. All normal human reactions. But there is a lack of openness. My antennas cannot channel the full glory of life. We all know this from our own lives: when we are overwhelmed, or guilty, or ashamed, or pulled in a thousand directions, or something is sitting heavy in our chest, we can force it all we want and nothing happens. Either I am open or I am not.

So Yonah, at Simchas Beis HaShoevah, has something open up in him and he experiences a divine flow. There were many prophets; we do not say of the others that they began at Simchas Beis HaShoevah. With Yonah, that is where it happened, and it was not something he planned. He came, and something opened. What opened? How exactly do you receive ruach hakodesh because people are dancing?

The Beis Hamikdash Is Not Only a Place

Over the years on Sukkos, the Lubavitcher Rebbe would farbreng and discuss many themes of Simchas Beis HaShoevah. What follows is built on that, the way I understood it and the way I want to apply it for today's generation.

To understand any of it, we need something fundamental. When we speak about the Beis Hamikdash, we are not speaking only about the past or only about the future. Of course it is both. But the experience is a constant one, because as the pasuk says, ועשו לי מקדש ושכנתי בתוכם — make Me a sanctuary and I will dwell not in it, but in them. Chazal point out that it should have said בתוכו. It says בתוכם because it means inside each and every single person. The Beis Hamikdash was a place that helped a person get in touch with the divine energy inside himself. It was not that you went there and all the action happened in that building; it was the place that inspired and empowered the experience internally.

Today there is no physical Beis Hamikdash, but there is still a physical person, a body and a soul. So ושכנתי בתוכם is fully applicable, and in many ways the avodah of the Beis Hamikdash is even deeper today, as it says in Likkutei Torah, because today I have to find it inside myself. I cannot say that somebody else is doing it on top of a mountain. The buck stops here.

The Rebbe Maharash said something beautiful. Chazal say אמירתו של הקדוש ברוך הוא חשובה מעשה — when Hashem says something, it is as though it is done. He spoke the world into existence. I can talk from today until tomorrow and nothing happens; Hashem's speech is action. So from the moment Hashem said ושכנתי בתוכם, the heart of every single Jew became a Beis Hamikdash. It was like a genetic mutation — from that moment, for eternity, the Jewish heart is a sanctuary. And the Rebbe Maharash added: when that Jew went up to the physical Beis Hamikdash, the great Beis Hamikdash was mirrored in the small Beis Hamikdash of his heart. They were never two separate things. We did not come as good tourists on a pilgrimage. There was an energetic connection, because the Mikdash already lives in the heart in miniature, and when the two met, your heart became an embodied reflection and continuum of the energy of the Mikdash.

So Simchas Beis HaShoevah is not merely a physical story of drawing water and pouring it — though it is that too, and we will resume it b'karov mamash with the third Beis Hamikdash, may it be even before this Sukkos. Alongside that, the primary element is experiential and embodied. What does it mean in a person's life?

The Covenant of Salt

For this, Rashi opens a window into the secret of Simchas Beis HaShoevah, through a verse that seems entirely unrelated — a verse about salt. In Parshas Vayikra, Vayikra chapter two, verse thirteen: וכל קרבן מנחתך במלח תמלח, ולא תשבית מלח ברית אלקיך מעל מנחתך; על כל קרבנך תקריב מלח.4 Every meal offering you shall salt with salt; you shall not omit the salt of the covenant of your God from upon your meal offering.

Any offering brought in the Mishkan or the Beis Hamikdash had to be salted before it was placed on the altar. When a human being eats, I understand — the salad needs a little salt, the soup needs a little salt, the challah needs a little salt, and oy vey if it wasn't salted. But here you are taking flour and placing it on the mizbeach, and it must first be salted. The same with all the animals. Even the wood — there was a korban of wood, and nobody eats wood, yet the wood was salted too. Everything was salted. And the Torah calls it a covenant with Hashem: do not omit this covenant.

Rashi explains: ברית כרותה למלח מששת ימי בראשית, שהובטחו המים התחתונים ליקרב במזבח במלח ונסוך המים בחג. A covenant was cut with salt from the six days of creation, for the lower waters were promised that they would be offered on the altar — through salt, which comes from the depths of the oceans, and through the water libations on the festival of Sukkos.

What is Rashi talking about? He is taking us back to the beginning of creation, to the concept of מים עליונים and מים תחתונים, higher waters and lower waters.

The Split of the Second Day

On the first day of creation Hashem created light; light was called day and darkness night. At that stage the Torah says ורוח אלקים מרחפת על פני המים, the spirit of Hashem hovering over the water. Then comes day two: יהי רקיע בתוך המים ויהי מבדיל בין מים למים. Let there be a firmament within the water, separating water from water. There is water above the rakia and water below it. Everything below eventually becomes all the oceans and seas and rivers and canals and springs and wells, every gathering of water in our world — and even rain, since rain is water drawn up from the oceans and returned from the clouds to irrigate the planet so we can survive. That is all the mayim tachtonim, the lower waters. And above the rakia are the mayim elyonim.

That happened on Monday — and Monday is the only day of creation on which the Torah does not say כי טוב. Every other day Hashem saw that it was good. Why not this one? Chazal say: because on that day machlokes was created. That was the first split, the first quarrel, between the higher water and the lower water.

And our sages say, as it says in the Zohar, that from that day מים תחתונים בוכין — the lower waters weep. What are they crying? אנן בעינן למהוי קדם מלכא — we want to stand before the King. What did we do to deserve being detached, to be placed beneath the rakia? We want to be there. So from that day the lower waters cry. And it is said in Kabbalah that בוכין is an acronym: beis, chaf, yud, mem — ברוך כבוד ה' ממקומו. That is precisely their cry: where is His place? We want to be before the King.

How did Hashem comfort the water? With two things. First, all the korbanos in the Beis Hamikdash will be offered with salt, which comes from the sea. Second, and more directly, the water itself: on Sukkos, every morning they will draw water and pour it on the mizbeach. That is the covenant He made with the lower waters in response to their anguish over the separation.

Why This Is Strange, and Why It Matters

Anyone who reads this should find it very strange. If separating the waters was wrong, then don't do it. If it was right, then simply tell the water that it is right. What does it even mean that the lower water is crying? What is it crying about? This is what God wanted — do the waters have their own vision of creation?

And how exactly is this a comfort? By the way, for eight days a year we will pour you on the altar. Okay, yasher koach. My partner upstairs gets to stay up there forever, and I am down here, detached, and for eight days they take a goblet of water and pour it on the mizbeach. How much water is it — three lugin? A cup? Not much at all. This is a consolation?

And here is the extraordinary thing. From this comes the entire Simchas Beis HaShoevah. And not only that — our sages say that if you did not see that simcha, you never saw simcha in your life. So something is at stake here so powerful that bringing this water and pouring it on the altar does not merely soothe a wound; it generates such an explosive simcha that there is no joy like it in the world.

The answer is that the story of the split waters, repaired on Sukkos, is not a story about water on top and water on the bottom. It is the internal story of the fabric of creation. The split of day two is the essential split that is the source of nearly all anxiety in a person's life. מים תחתונים בוכין is not water weeping over which piece of the birthday cake it got. It is an essential outcry — and Sukkos, and the pouring of the water, is the response to it.

Water Is Life, Water Is Pleasure

Water is the source of life. A fetus in the womb develops enveloped in water. Seventy percent of every cell is water, which means most of our body, though it doesn't look it, is water. We don't only drink water in order to hydrate and survive; water is essentially life, which is why life begins in water. We take water for granted and we never should, because water equals life.

Water also represents pleasure, taanug — the flow of it. You feel it practically. You go to the ocean, you go to the beach, there is something deeply, sensually pleasurable about water. It generates the growth of every delicacy and fruit and vegetable and grain. Mayim represents flow: a flow of inspiration, a flow of enlightenment, a flow of pleasure.

So when we speak of higher water and lower water, we mean that on Sunday there was no higher and lower — there was one water. Then came a split, and from that split there are two waters. What does that split look like in a person's life?

Notice that day one in Bereishis is not called יום ראשון. It is called יום אחד. Rashi asks why it should not have said ראשון, first, since the next day is שני, second. Because on day one there was only echד — היה הקדוש ברוך הוא יחיד בעולמו. There was no split. In the consciousness of day one there is one source of life, one source of bliss, one source of pleasure: channeling the Divine. There is no other definition of pleasure, no other definition of happiness, no other definition of bliss. Because in truth there is one living source of everything, and that source is the source of all goodness.

Elokim Chaim — A God Who Is Life

Every day of the Aseres Yemei Teshuvah we say: זכרנו לחיים, מלך חפץ בחיים, וכתבנו בספר החיים, למענך אלקים חיים. Remember us for life, King who desires life, write us in the Book of Life, for Your sake, God of life. It is not merely a poem that repeats the word chaim. It is saying that Elokim is chaim. Hashem is life.

The worst thing a person can do to Hashem is turn Him into an object — a being, an entity, physical or even spiritual — so that there is Hashem and there is me. It is not Hashem and me. Hashem is the flow of life. It is an embodied experience.

There are two ways of living. One is dead, one is alive. Dead means that life becomes a set of objects. Everything is a thing — even my heart is a thing, one thing next to another thing. And that is torturous. Real life is that there is a flow. Hashem is not some thing living in the clouds or in the heavens. We relate to things as beings, whether physical or spiritual, but here you are dealing with life itself. It cannot be described as an entity, because it is a dynamic. Words exist to describe things: this is a table, this is a bottle, this is a person, this is a machine. But how do you describe life? It's a flow. It's a living, pulsating energy. Elokim is chaim. Being in that life means I am in flow; I am channeling the presence of life. That is day one.

Low-Hanging Fruit: The Consciousness of the Lower Waters

What happens on day two? The water splits, and from that day there are two competing definitions of bliss, two definitions of what life is, two definitions of what happiness could be. There is a higher consciousness and a lower consciousness.

The lower consciousness we all recognize instantly: I am looking for happiness to fill me. And there are a great many candidates, some of them genuinely exciting. Whoever dies with the most toys wins. Toys are fun, let's face it — especially when I'm one and two and three years old. The problem is that sometimes I don't grow out of toys; my toys just expand. At two it was a fire truck; at fifty or sixty I have bigger hasagos of what a toy is. In the olden days, for the afikoman, if your father was rich you got a Parker pen. Today you give a child a Parker pen and they'll call child services on you. They want a private jet, a yacht, a Lamborghini — okay, if your mother is a schnorrer you can buy me a tablet, but anything less? The hasagos change; essentially I am still chasing possessions.

And sometimes they are spiritual toys, not physical ones. What is a spiritual toy? An aliyah in shul, certainly. But it can go much further, and this is sensitive: it can be using religion to satisfy my anxiety or my underlying ego, using religion for approval, using even Hashem because He is on my checklist, because this is the authority I grew up with, so I use Him. And at the end the heart is tortured, because the only real bliss in the world comes from the ego and the insecurity surrendering into oneness. It is never a competition of when I will finally get Hashem to do what I want — that premise assumes two separate realities in which He holds all the power, and by definition that breeds anxiety and sometimes even resentment, even if it is hard to admit.

This is all very normal, because the water genuinely did split. We live in a world where intuitively I do not look to ego death as the source of bliss. I look to gather more, possess more, control more, own more. Even if I am a very nice person, not a control freak at all, tolerant of others — internally I often stay small and safe and in control, because I have no mechanism for what it even means to let go, to lean into trust and faith and surrender, which is always where the frequency of bliss lives.

So מים תחתונים בוכין is a perpetual state of existence. All the fragmented parts of us are searching for something, carrying an essential anxiety. Not an anxiety because somebody did something wrong — an essential anxiety. Sensitive people don't realize this and look for the source of their anxiety everywhere else. The deepest anxiety is the lower waters crying. The soul comes from a space of infinity, and the very detachment from that is a painful experience. To know that is a blessing.

All the discomfort I have in life is my attempt to heal that. But I don't know it, so I get a memo: this is missing in your life, and this, and this. Maybe it's even true. So I chase what's missing, I try to fix this one and that one and everybody, maybe even myself. What is actually missing is that I am not aligned with the source of life.

Rays of the Same Sun

The only real experience of joy in a person's life is when he is subsumed in the infinite reality of Hashem. When Yosef Yitzchak Jacobson stops being a separate entity that has to protect itself and build itself up and get certain things and control certain things, and I can truly say: I am completely fine, I am channeling the infinite light. I am not life — Hashem is life, and we are all channeling life, the way a ray of the sun channels the sun.

No ray gets upset at another ray. I have never seen a ray of sunlight come into this beautiful building and say, I don't like the other ray going into that house on Viola, because I want to be the only ray. The sun has enough light for everybody's ray. The other ray takes nothing away from this one. The moment you are channeling that, nobody can take anything away from anybody. My integrity cannot be diminished by somebody else's integrity — unless I am living a fakeness, unless I am trying to borrow something from you.

It is striking that the word in Tanach for the abyss, for purgatory, is שאול — שאול תחתית. שאול is the same letters as שאול, borrowed. Because whenever I am borrowing somebody else's life, that is the definition of the abyss. I look around: oh, she has something, he has something — emotionally, psychologically, financially. It is a very normal thing. But when you are actually alive, when you are in that flow, it's amazing. Hashem is not jealous of somebody having a nice house.

That is זכרנו לחיים. Remember the part of me that is alive. I don't want to live with the part of me that is dead. When I live in separation I am pouring life into something dead — it is like investing in a Ponzi scheme. There is nothing really there, so I have to keep rebuilding it. Making my ego believe that it is valuable is the hardest work in the world. It is avodas perech, because I am taking something that does not really exist and trying to infuse it with fake life. It is an exhausting existence, and the heart always knows the difference.

Which Fruits Hang Low

How tempting the alternative is. They call them low-hanging fruit. If the fruit hangs low you simply reach out; if it hangs high you have to climb, and that's an effort.

If I'm stressed out, food is low-hanging fruit — my pantry is full of it, my refrigerator is full of it. Drinks are low-hanging fruit. Ego is low-hanging fruit. Guilt is extremely low-hanging; how long does it take a Jewish mother to feel guilty? Not three seconds — you're already there. Shame is low-hanging. Resentment and blame hang tremendously low; it is very easy to grab on and start blaming. Or telling stories, figuring people out. You think Wikipedia is sophisticated? Wikipedia doesn't come close to your brain. We keep a file on everybody, because positioning myself against everybody else at least makes me feel safe in my own imagination.

And all these fruits are deeply affected by gravity. They pull you down, because they themselves are constantly being dragged downward. The higher fruit is mayim elyonim, and it isn't subject to that gravity: the frequencies of trust, surrender, love, emunah, bliss, humility, open-heartedness, ceding control.

The lower water gets very upset at this. If you give up control your life will be a mess, your house will be a churban, your kids won't be taken care of, you'll be the most irresponsible person alive. Oh, so now you're going to sit on the couch and meditate with Rabbi YY's classes about surrender and bliss? And who's making Sukkos? Let him make Sukkos. I have a deal: let him come to the house and prepare the whole Yom Tov, and I'll go meditate about bliss and sip my iced coffee — God, thank you for this beautiful gift of Sukkos, I'm so stressed out. And let him build my sukkah while he's at it. These are fair questions, since I also have to build a sukkah, and fix an awning, and do a few other things.

So we don't live in mayim elyonim. We live in the split.

I want to quote something very wise I heard from my wife. I heard it secondhand, at a Tanya class in Michal Foyer's home some time ago, right before Rosh Hashanah. A woman can say this to women; I couldn't say it myself, but I'm quoting my wife, so I can repeat it. She was speaking about the stress people carry on Yom Tov — wanting it beautiful for the guests, for themselves, for their spouses, for the atmosphere — and what it costs between the cooking and the cleaning and the help and the organizing. I don't need to preach about that to this room. But ask someone, why are you doing all of this? And they'll say, because it's Yom Tov. So what is this Yom Tov? It was before Rosh Hashanah — the Yom Tov is שתמליכוני עליכם, that I coronate Hashem as King. And if Hashem is the King, it means you can give up control. So for the sake of the Yom Tov I become more stressed, when the entire point of the Yom Tov is to crown Hashem as King.

That paradox is part of life, because I get stuck in the experience itself. It is so much easier to reach for the low-hanging fruit, where I feel in control, than to return again and again, every single day, to deeper breathing, deeper presence, deeper alignment, deeper trust.

The Tug of War I Watch in Myself

Let me make this visceral, because I know the struggle from the inside.

I give a lot of classes. Sometimes I finish a shiur and, baruch Hashem, it went very well. It was obvious — nobody fell asleep, nobody was texting. I could see that people were touched, and I could feel it in the air and in myself. Then somebody comes over and says, that was the most beautiful class I ever heard, that was life-changing, you opened my heart.

And I can mamish watch a tug of war inside me. I can see it with my mind's x-ray. One part of me wants to own that. Wants to take it home and live off it, kvell off those words — because at that moment, so to speak, I own him, I own his energy, he owes his life to me. I want to grab it and run home with it, like the story of Kelm with the moon: you put the lid on and you've got the moon. What's better to bring home than the moon? You're going to go home with a hundred dollars? The moon is something to bring home; that's something to tell your friends. And if a second person comes by, and then a third, they're confirming it.

And yet another part of me knows that this is a death sentence, because I am building up something that does not exist. I don't own it. It was wisdom I had the zechus to receive, that Hashem channeled through me because He wanted to use me as a channel. I'm privileged. It's a beautiful feeling. But the moment I want to hijack it, I'm stealing from God.

A woman once wrote a beautiful line: creativity is eavesdropping on God. Now, if you eavesdrop on my conversation and then publish it and sell two million copies, you're a gonif — at least say you were eavesdropping. All creativity is eavesdropping on Hashem. I'm a creator, I created something — that is what the word creativity means, you are channeling creation from the Creator. That's what makes you creative. So you had the zechus to eavesdrop on Hashem. Beautiful. Now you have the privilege of sharing what you overheard. Say that. Thank you for letting me be a channel. That is not torturous at all.

The ego doesn't like that. You're an idiot, take it home, hijack it. But this is literally the choice between building something dead — which will look alive only until the next criticism, which arrives in three minutes, after which I wait for the next compliment, which arrives in six — and bringing it all back to life. Because You are Elokim chaim. You are not a God of death.

And how does the heart know it is alive? Only one way: when it feels itself channeling Elokim chaim. Suddenly it's alive. It isn't defensive. It doesn't need to hijack anything. It doesn't need control. It is calm and serene, because it isn't in a defensive posture — you're right, I'm right, I'll score a point, but I said this and you said that. When I'm in that posture, I'm in a posture of death.

I should add a disclaimer, because people hear this and ask: so you're not allowed to compliment anybody? Of course you are. If somebody tells me after a class that it was good, I'm not going to take you to a din Torah for putting me in a posture of death. Feedback helps a person see his impact and his influence and where he can grow; that is very special. But there are two kinds of feedback. There is feedback that becomes my oxygen — and I need to know where I am getting my oxygen from. And there is feedback that functions as a guide, a blueprint, a map. It is critical to distinguish between the two.

The same tug of war appears everywhere. I happen to be a curious person. I hear something, I see something, and I want to know more. Then I have to ask myself: which part of me wants this information? We have conversations about people — it's not lashon hara, we're just trying to help them. Fine. But I have to go into my honest heart and ask, which part of me is curious here? Is it the part that's alive and dancing with Hashem, or the part looking for a resurrection, hoping that if the information is juicy enough I'll feel good for eight minutes until the next conversation? Whatever is happening in that person's life is largely irrelevant to me. If there's something I can help with, tell me and I'll help. Beyond that — where do I have five minutes to dissect somebody's life when there's plenty going on in here? Who gains? Do they gain? No. Do I grow? No.

Choosing the Living Part of Everything

Moshe Rabbeinu says at the end of his life: ובחרת בחיים — there is life and there is death, choose life. The Alter Rebbe asks: everybody chooses life. An animal chooses life. An insect chooses life. Do I need Moshe Rabbeinu to tell me to choose life?

And the answer he gives is profound. In everything there is a living part and a dead part. The living part is what reflects Elokim chaim. The dead part is what is not really alive — what is trying to make itself alive by covering up and building up something fake. ובחרת בחיים: in everything, always choose the living part.

Chazal say that the wicked, even while they are alive, are called dead. Why? They are not dead. They may be healthy and robust and accomplishing a great deal. But there is an inner deadness. When my heart is not channeling Elokim chaim, there is a deadness inside, and I feel it — a kind of boredom. People say, I'm bored. What is boredom, really? Boredom is dissociation. Hashem is not boring. Life is never boring. Life was never boring and I promise you it never will be — not because you have a lot of drama, but because life is an infinite, vibrating, pulsating reality of living presence. It cannot be boring. What can be boring is me, when I'm not in touch with it — when I become a dead object looking for something to fill me. So I'm bored here and bored there.

Cooking is a perfect example of all this. If the food becomes the litmus test of my worth — is it good, is everybody enjoying it — that is the classic case.

Which Book Am I Writing?

Sukkos is not the relief of Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur being over so we can finally chill out. Sukkos is the culmination of Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur, because those are the days when a person can identify, more easily than at any other time, what makes him alive and what does not. That is why it is the season of asking to be written in the Book of Life.

We sometimes take that simply — that I should live this year. And of course, as we say in Unesaneh Tokef, מי יחיה ומי ימות. But there is something deeply emotional in it as well. To be written into the Book of Life means that every person is always writing his own book. Every moment of life we are writing a book — זה ספר תולדות אדם. Not necessarily with a pen or a quill. Everything we say, do or think leaves an imprint in the world forever; וכל מעשיך בספר נכתבים. So which book am I writing? A book of life, or a book of the opposite of life? When I catch myself and say, that juicy conversation is not contributing to my heart's life — because for the heart to be alive it must be channeling Hashem's infinity — I am choosing which sefer I am writing.

Then comes the joy of Sukkos: the expression of that yechidah, that oneness, in the most visceral way. And this is where the water comes in. The lower water is carried up and poured on the mizbeach. It becomes a korban, an offering. And that is what erupted into Simchas Beis HaShoevah.

Why It Had to Be Said in the Negative

Now we can answer why it is stated in the negative. They are not saying that Simchas Beis HaShoevah was a great simcha, or even the greatest simcha. They are saying: if you did not see this, you never saw joy at all. Because they are telling us the ultimate truth about human life.

Everybody is looking for joy, constantly. Let's face it — that is what motivates most of what we do, or at least a wildly disproportionate share of it. Maybe I don't call it joy. Maybe I call it relief. Maybe I call it giving my parents nachas. Maybe I call it fitting into the community, doing the right thing, not being deemed the bad girl. There's a conveyor belt: you hatch them, you match them, you dispatch them, and there's a preconceived notion that if you stay on the belt everything will be perfect — until it isn't. Some children work with that conveyor belt: just invite me to the bar mitzvah and I'll pay half. And some children are already saying, we're not going with this cycle. So much of life is the pursuit of some kind of wholeness: just make me feel good, or at least make me feel I'm doing the right thing, that You like me, Hashem, that You won't punish me.

And on this our sages, in their inimitable way, compress dozens of volumes of philosophy, psychology, theology and emotional health into a single line: מי שלא ראה שמחת בית השואבה לא ראה שמחה מימיו. How do they know nobody was ever happy? Because what they are saying is this: if you did not deal with the split between the higher water and the lower water in your own life, and realize that the only way the lower water is healed is by helping it return to its source — while still acknowledging its unique mission as lower water — then you have never seen simcha. Because any other simcha in the world is by definition an attempt to give meaning to an existence that remains essentially wounded.

They are not being pessimistic or begrudging. What do they have against other simchas? If somebody has a beautiful house, what should happen — should you die? But they are saying the most healing thing there is. If I have not confronted the split, and brought the lower water up in nisuch hamayim, and understood at the same time that it remains lower water — because we do not pour all the oceans and all the canals onto the mizbeach; it has a role precisely as lower water — then I know that I never experienced simcha in my life, because all my other simchas were me straining after something.

The only real simcha in life happens when I am finally ready to crack open my ego, my insecurity, my mayim tachtonim, my separateness, and let go. I tried everything else. I tried a great deal in the context of religion. Even religion can be this. Even Yiddishkeit can be this. I can learn a lot of Torah, become a big talmid chacham, do many mitzvos, do tremendous chesed — genuinely holy, sacred things that carry real reward — and still, deep down, feel detached. Why? Because even though the Torah is real and godly, and the mitzvah is real and godly, and the tzedakah is real and godly, the energy inside it can be an energy that isn't alive. It can be torturous, because I am using Yiddishkeit to fill my guilt and shame and void while building up something essentially separate. In a way it becomes even more toxic: I'm using oneness to fuel fragmentation. I'm using divinity — which is the inclusivity of everything and the death of all separateness — to feed my own separateness. That is why the test in this kind of work is always the same: if it is not making me more humble, and more humble, and more humble still, with more love for people, with more ahavas Yisrael, then something is off. If it turns me into "look how enlightened I am," the person is completely detached.

Otherwise I am trying to lift myself up by pulling on my own hair. Have you ever tried it? Who is doing the pulling? My ego is trying to get rid of my ego. My guilt is trying to get rid of my guilt. My separateness is trying to get rid of my separateness. I'm trying to outsmart God, and the inner critic never stops, so I force it harder and harder. What it actually needs is a pause — to observe everything, and to understand that there is something precious in the mayim tachtonim.

The split was not a mistake. The purpose of the split is מחצתי ואני ארפא, to heal it — to take the lower waters and bring them back up to their source. That is why it was split, and that is why there is always hope. It was not split in order to remain split. It was split in order to create the momentum, the catalyst, the possibility for a person to choose, with his own agency and creativity, to bring it back to Elokim chaim. In pure oneness there is no choice and no relationship; you are simply part of Him. Hashem wanted a relationship, and that is what malchus is. Relationship requires that you be separate. And now, instead of choosing separateness, I can choose. I can observe all of this. I can feel the pain of mayim tachtonim, and that is not a tragedy. And then I can say: and this mayim tachtonim is now going back to the Source.

What Your Soul Is Made Of

You will say: come on, what about three hundred million dollars? Three hundred million in the bank is a very good thing, and everybody should have it — say amen. You could do amazing things with it, give enormous tzedakah, build a beautiful world. All of that is good, and a gift, and a privilege. And all of it is mayim tachtonim.

The inner experience of contentment, of once experiencing Ein Sof in your nervous system, is not simply better. It is a different magnitude. A different inyan entirely. You'll say, you're hakking a tshaynik, forget your maaselach and your Ein Sof, send your Ein Sof to Hawaii, I'll take the three hundred million. I understand that money is good, that we all need money, that everybody should have money, and that it helps enormously when a person is not struggling financially. I don't minimize that, chas v'shalom. Hashem created a world with money, and with money we buy things — toys, and hopefully some important things too.

But we have to know the nekudah. Your soul is not made up of money. Your soul is made up of God. That is a very big difference. Three hundred million is a tremendous gift, but it is not what your soul is made of. People think they are made of that because they don't know who they are. If a person is given such a gift, it is a beautiful zechus like any other talent Hashem distributes — financial, moral, emotional, spiritual — and it comes with a shlichus to illuminate the world with it and bring people closer to the truth. Exactly as when someone gives me a compliment, I can say it is a zechus to share this wisdom; so too it is a zechus to share money, whatever a person's gifts are. But when the gift becomes detached and turns into a substitute for the Source, it becomes an endless source of inner void and inner anxiety.

When the heart space experiences even once the flow of life, of Hashem moving through your nervous system, you are safe. You are whole. Not because I am perfect, but because perfection is being channeled through me, because I am part of perfection. The idea that you are evil at your core is ridiculous. It is ludicrous. You are divine at your core. We have our separateness, which we struggle with and must work with. But that is why there is no simcha like this one.

There is no simcha like the child who was held captive in Gaza and comes home to his mother after two years in Hamas's purgatory. That embrace — nothing in the world comes close to it. The soul is essentially a חלק אלוק ממעל, purely divine. Your heart is infinite. But it can be so lodged in the abyss of שאול, in borrowing other people's lives. And when that water came up to the mizbeach, the souls instinctively danced all night — because the part of you that has been in exile your entire life, that you may never even have known about, was coming home.

There are such moments in a person's life. Not every moment; I'm not claiming we can live there constantly. But I remember once having such an experience. I grew up with a great deal of anxiety inside me, and there was a moment when I felt the anxiety lift — not forever, for a few minutes — and I could feel my heart simply channeling the light coming through it. There is no substitute for that. Give me every comfortable and beautiful thing in the world, which I will appreciate and cherish, and it cannot replace the inner ושכנתי בתוכם, when your heart is the Beis Hamikdash and the great Mikdash is reflected in the small one. Suddenly there is an inner peace of knowing not merely that you matter, but of experiencing yourself. Not telling yourself, I matter, I matter — that doesn't do it. The experience of the heart flowing with Elokim chaim. No ego there. No defensiveness. Nothing to prove. Just is-ness, in the deepest space, in flow.

That is exactly what they mean by לא ראה שמחה מימיו. You cannot get any other simcha, because every other simcha, if it is not this simcha of returning yourself to the Source by cracking open — there isn't even a close second.

Yonah: The Dove and the Deceived

Now we come back to Yonah. The Zohar takes the entire story of Yonah and reads it as a metaphor for life. Who is Yonah? Yonah is the soul. Every person has a soul called Yonah. It enters the body, which is the boat. The world is the ocean — turbulent, overwhelming; without a boat I would sink. So the body holds up the neshamah, and the neshamah travels through the world in its guf.

Why is it called Yonah? In Hebrew יונה is a dove. But it comes from another word as well: הונאה, deception, mistreatment — ולא תונו איש את עמיתו, do not deceive your fellow. The Zohar says the soul is called Yonah because once it becomes bound up in the body, it is easily deceived.

So the name holds two opposites. A dove represents loyalty and devotion. It is one of the only creatures in the world that keeps a faithful, monogamous bond for life; most animals have no such loyalty, but doves remain with their mate. The dove represents dedication and love. And the same word means deception.

That is the story of the soul. Yonah comes into the body, and very often it is deceived by life. What is the deception? The soul is not made of money, not made of ego, not made of validation, not made of control. Its chemistry is Elokus; its chemistry is infinity. You can throw everything at it and it says: this doesn't do it. But the body and the world tell the soul, no — this is how you get your simcha. So I try this, and I try that. And it can even happen in a religious context. I live in a frum community, I do the right things, I have a beautiful Torah-dike home, Sukkos will be geshmak — and my heart space is closed, because I am using Hashem and Torah and mitzvos to feel good about a wounded self without ever really letting go.

And I don't even know there is anything else, because this is what everyone does. I look at my sisters, I look at my mother, and everyone seems to be having nachas, everyone seems happy — און איך בין די משוגענע. Maybe you are simply more authentic, a little more sensitive, a little more curious, seeing through a little more. That's why you ended up in this class. But it is never about anybody else; the moment we go to other people we have already left the space. Internally, when the heart is channeling the Source, the soul is not being deceived. It knows exactly what simcha is, and nothing can replace it.

I know this in myself, constantly. Sometimes I want to be distracted, I want to go to that other place — and no, I'm being duped. It's like being hungry and seeing a piece of food that looks good and eating it in a weak moment, and ten minutes later knowing you deceived yourself. It wasn't good. It was toxic. The same is true of thoughts and words and behaviors, twenty-four hours a day.

בכל דרכיך דעהו is not a curse; it's a gift. People hear it as a sentence: you always have to be connected to Hashem, give me a break, everybody gets a vacation, I connect with You enough. No. דעהו means connection — and knowing, as in וידע אדם את חוה. It means I can always be alive. I can always choose connection, always choose an open heart. That's a pretty good gift. And I can also choose the other way. It is hard to choose life, because choosing life means being disciplined, being present, not distracting myself. It's easy to pick up the phone and spend two hours on Netflix or something else, two hours of not thinking, dead, deaf, dumb and blind, thoroughly entertained. And after those two hours the heart hasn't opened. We know the difference immediately. It is a subtle difference and an utterly profound one.

Why It Happened to Yonah, There

Yonah is the one who runs away from God. What does that actually look like? It happens when the lower water stops crying and says: why am I crying? This is it, this is all there is. That is running away from Hashem.

You can't run away from Hashem, though we try. Running away doesn't necessarily mean fleeing to Hawaii or Alaska or New Zealand — and anyway, there's Chabad there too, they'll find you. Maybe Mars, though today there may be Chabad on Mars as well. I'm speaking about a different kind of flight. There is running away physically and there is running away emotionally. Running away emotionally means taking the lower water, detaching it, and declaring: you are not lower, you are the higher water. Instead of feeling the tension and using it as a catalyst for growth, I announce that there is no more tension — and I begin worshipping the lower water. That is what it means to run from Hashem: to run from the truth that reality is one, that I am a humble servant, that I have no separate existence. It is not easy to stay in that truth, so I flee. I'm done with You. All the calculations are lovely, but now I need my own little ego space, my insecurity space, and that's where I want to live. That is Yonah. He was duped.

And then he came to Simchas Beis HaShoevah, and he healed, and ruach hakodesh rested on him. The same Yonah. What happened there? He saw it all. He saw the clarity. He saw that all the pain, all the confusion, all the anxiety, all the separateness of all those years — that was the mayim tachtonim crying. Not because he is genuinely separate; separateness is unnatural. At Simchas Beis HaShoevah he received the healing. He saw that the separation was created only so that a person, by his own initiative and choice and courage, could bring it all back.

So Yonah experiences divine inspiration not despite his previous life but because of it. His entire life experience suddenly coheres, because now there is meaning in all the separation and all the tension. People struggle with things for many years. It isn't separation — it is working through the oneness inside your separation. It is bringing Hashem into every fiber of your being, which means I have to work through this part of my life, and these emotions, and this experience. Everybody's story is different. It is bringing the lower water back up, but this time with an unprecedented force that can only come from separation that is then reunited.

Because there is no joy like the unity of two inseparable friends who were fragmented and separated and then really, truly came back. Now they own the friendship. Rav Aharon of Sarshala writes this: how do you know two people are really friends? While they're close, growing up together, fine. But when they fall into a terrible fight and are separated, and the entire world tells them never to reconnect — and something inside them aches, and they are drawn to each other, and they reconnect — then you see that the connection is who they are in their essence, and no circumstance could ever sever it.

A marriage is always as deep as a couple's capacity to handle a real argument. If you always agree with each other, it's wonderful, and I don't mean to disturb it. But let's be honest: probably one of you isn't being fully honest, or is shutting down. If a husband and wife are both fully present in their personalities, and both of them are Jewish, there are going to be differences, sometimes profound ones. Can they come out? When they can come out, even creating a wedge, and you not only survive it but come closer through it because each of you brought your authenticity — then you can say, we truly choose each other. We're not forced to be together; we choose each other, knowing the differences. There is no deeper connection than that.

The soul in Heaven is one with Hashem. Then it becomes separate. It has every reason to be distracted, overwhelmed, to go searching for other simchas. And it searches and searches, and something is never quite right. And then, on Sukkos, it finally breaks through and cracks open, and the water comes back to be poured on the mizbeach. That is Simchas Beis HaShoevah: לא ראה שמחה מימיו. The greatest simcha, where you finally own the relationship. You own the oneness. You own the absence of ego. You own being truly connected to the Source. And the heart pounds with the celebration of your truest essence reclaimed in a way that can never again be taken from you — knowing that all the darkness that was there the whole time was only a method and an opportunity to work through it and reclaim it.

Bringing It Home

Now, practically, what is the homework? People are cleaning and sweeping and mopping and cooking. Every person's life is different and each of us has to apply this in a personal and intimate way. But at least one aspect is this: in these days, dedicate time every morning to actually live in this space. The morning, when we are fresh and awake.

The Baal Shem Tov says that the first thoughts of the morning affect the entire day. They are the opening; they set the tone. So spend time in the morning sitting with your neshamah. When you say אלקי, נשמה שנתת בי טהורה היא, pause. Take it in. This is not fiction. This is the realest thing there is. A great many things are happening in your life — what is the most real thing? The most real thing in the world is love. The most real thing in the world is connection. The deepest thing in the world is that you are one with Hashem. That counts more than anything else.

The Baal Shem Tov called it dveikus. Dveikus is the beginning and the end of everything: connection, oneness, attachment. That is our deepest need and our deepest desire. And the attachment begins between me and me. I cannot be attached to people if I have not found my attachment needs met in my own soul — because then I'm coming to you needing you to say this and do that, and if my wife doesn't say it, if my husband doesn't say it, I'm a wreck for the rest of the day. Of course it's wonderful when people give us validation and feedback. But it starts with knowing who you are. Can I really know what I'm looking for? What is my deepest, deepest need?

Sometimes that comes with a lot of pain, because of different disappointments in life. And still to say: in all this pain, I am not alone. I am not lonely. I am not merely separated water looking for something to numb it. I know the pain precisely because I am looking for real attachment, real connection.

And I can also watch all the other parts of me that are making me crazy and dragging me in a thousand directions. Going into this space does not silence everything else — halevai it worked that way. If you can get there, wonderful. But far more likely, two or three voices will pipe up: stop fooling yourself, stop lying to yourself, you know how messed up you are, you know it doesn't work. And by the way, look what time it is, you're late again, you're never on time, you can't get your life together, why can't you learn from your neighbors? Watch all of that. Every one of those voices is speaking because it is trying to protect you — from embarrassment, from shame, from whatever it is. I can watch it all and hold space for it with kindness and compassion. And then lean a little deeper into the heart and ask: what is it really? What are you really, really looking for? If this person says something nice to me, will that be the beginning and end of all my tzaros? Is it this possession, that possession? The truth is you're looking for yourself. You're looking for Hashem. מים תחתונים בוכין: ברוך כבוד ה' ממקומו.

And I lean into that, and I surrender into trust. It doesn't mean I'm lazy. It doesn't mean I won't cook. It doesn't mean I won't build my sukkah or that I'll sit on the couch doing nothing. It means I want to be energized from a place of life rather than from a place of death. Not driven — go do this, go do that — and then freaking out. Energized from connection.

I'm going to cook. Why am I cooking? Really, why? Am I cooking for validation, so the food will be perfect and they'll say, I never ate such a rib steak in my life? Or can I find my oneness with Hashem in the cooking? And then, maybe, I can let some things go. I don't mean to mix into anybody's kitchen, but sometimes people cook to perfection and need every conceivable dip in the world. (And sometimes they make it too sugary.) If you can hold onto the fact that you are doing this out of your connection with Hashem, because it is a privilege to bring joy and love and nurture to your family and to yourself, it becomes a different kind of experience. I can let go of a few things. I don't have to be perfect. I can buy some things ready-made — as long as it has no seed oil, chas v'shalom, at least according to what they say about me in my circles. I can delegate.

And then you don't abandon yourself in the process. Abandoning yourself doesn't help a family. Do you think any child or grandchild wants a mother or grandmother on Sukkos who is depleted, exhausted, and carrying a heaviness that everyone can feel — secretly wishing the Yom Tov had never come? Nobody wants that. People would rather have less food and more presence. I know that's not a very Jewish thing to say, but it's true. Ask your children whether they want more of their mother's heart space with less food, or perfect five-star food with a mother who is depleted, stressed and angry. Ask any child in the world. They may not say it out loud, but everybody knows the answer.

Don't answer, well, we can't have both — if I'm relaxed there'll be no food and everyone will starve all Sukkos, and then they certainly won't be happy. I'm not suggesting your house should have nothing. I'm saying the food is an expression of self, not the other way around. In a home, in a family, the first thing is to be present. Elokim chaim. You are channeling Hashem's energy into the world, and that is what you give people more than anything else. I promise you. You can make a hundred potato kugels, tzugezungen un tzugezogt, and I'm sure whoever eats it will go pssst, pssst. But that pssst lasts three and a half seconds, maybe ten seconds, maybe three minutes. Your heart space lasts a lifetime. That is where everyone wants to invest; that is the relationship field.

As mature adults we each have to work out how to do this efficiently. It always helps to dedicate time in the morning — ten minutes, half an hour, forty-five minutes — to davening, to learning, to a walk, to listening to classes like these, in a way that actually connects. Nurture that part of you. And then, when I show up, yes, I have a great deal to do today, b'ezras Hashem. But why am I doing it? I don't have to prove myself to anybody. I'm not looking for validation. I'm not trying to be perfect or to impress anyone or to score points. I want to be a shliach, an ambassador of Hashem, joining the higher waters and the lower waters until they fuse.

And then the Simchas Beis HaShoevah in our own heart — לא ראה שמחה מימיו. It takes every simcha in the world and elevates all of them, because they all become part of your attachment and your connection. Have a beautiful, uplifted, joyous, serene, extraordinary, blessed Yom Tov.

Sources

  1. Tehillim 100:2 עבדו את־י-ה-ו-ה בשמחה באו לפניו ברננה׃ ↩
  2. Succah 51b ↩
  3. Jerusalem Talmud Sukkah 5:1 ↩
  4. Vayikra 2:13 וכל־קרבן מנחתך במלח תמלח ולא תשבית מלח ברית אלקיך מעל מנחתך על כל־קרבנך תקריב מלח׃ ↩