The Song the Soul Is Searching For
The Tree and the Forest
Teshuvah is usually translated as repentance or return, and when we speak about it the focus is almost always on details. A person apologizes for a misdeed, for an inappropriate behavior, for a text message, for a comment, for a fight, for a dispute. He apologizes to himself, to his soul, to Hashem, to another person. I want to fix this. I want to repair this. I want to make a tikkun for this. And that is vital, because in life, when things are left hanging in the air and never brought down to a granular level, they simply remain elusive. Nothing changes.
But there is another side to this. When a person focuses only on the details, on every single tree, he can lose sight of the forest. Of course, if I want a piece of fruit I need a tree, not a forest — the forest will not hand me an apple. And I can hug a tree; people do that. You cannot hug a forest. Yet if you divorce the tree from the forest, you have lost the real story of the tree itself, because a tree is only truly understood inside an entire ecosystem.
So it is with teshuvah. There is the teshuvah on the individual item: something I failed to do, something I failed to live up to, remorse for the past and resolution for the future, whether בין אדם למקום or בין אדם לחבירו. And then there is the larger perspective — which matters not because a panoramic view is interesting, but because it lifts the details themselves onto an entirely different plateau. Every individual act of teshuvah is an extension of a far larger, far deeper experience of teshuvah.
That larger experience is harder to talk about. Tell me XYZ and I will make a to-do list — step one, step two, make this phone call, send that WhatsApp. Very tangible. I have my tree. The deeper level is less tangible, but far more fruitful.
Treating the Symptom or Treating the Cause
It is like a person with symptoms. Back pain — which Jew doesn't have back pain? Neck pain, lower back, upper back. We can spend an entire life chasing the symptoms: make this feel better, make that feel better. And if there is something you can do to relieve pain, do it, gevaldik. But very often the outer symptom is the expression of an inner dynamic that is far less conscious, far less visible, far less tangible — something no aspirin will touch.
Dr. Sarno, the Jewish doctor who developed a whole method about back pain and who passed away a few years ago, spent close to forty years as a conventional Western physician doing surgery after surgery after surgery — not tens of patients, not hundreds, but thousands over decades. And he found that in a large share of the cases everything came back. He was astonished; from everything he had been taught, something was off. The science itself catapulted him into asking whether there is a deeper story behind back pain, behind neck pain, behind sciatica. His conclusion was that the body is protecting me from feeling a deeper pain it senses I am not ready to confront. So it keeps me busy 24/7 — my back, my neck, oy gevald, I can't. In the body's brilliance, it distracts me precisely because it does not think I am ready.
Really, you have to send your body a memo: I'm a big boy. I'm a big girl. Bring it on. I'm ready to deal with it. Easier said than done, because it sits very deep inside. But the principle is everything. If I only treat the symptom, I go in circles; if it doesn't surface here, it will surface there, and there, and there.
The devil is in the details, they say. להבדיל, teshuvah is also in the details. But the details are always expressions — arteries, channels, veins, vessels for a larger stream. The work is to connect the two.
כלל, פרט, וכלל
This is precisely why every morning, before davening, we learn the passage of רבי ישמעאל אומר, the thirteen methods by which Torah is interpreted. Among them are כלל ופרט, פרט וכלל, כלל ופרט וכלל. There is a כלל, a collective; the כלל is then fleshed out into פרטים, details; and then you must bring the details back up to the כלל.
That is the structure of life itself. Everything begins as כלל — oneness, ה' אחד. It descends into פרט, the individual form of every life. But do not get stuck in the פרט. Bring the פרט back to the כלל — and that second כלל is deeper than the first, because the original כלל was a oneness that preceded details, while the second comes through them and after them.
During the עשרת ימי תשובה a Jew's sensitivities are heightened; you simply absorb more. The anxiety people feel this time of year is not about one thing or another, and it is not really about punishment or negativity, though that is how it presents itself. It is an existential anxiety, and it comes from a very positive and loving place — once you understand it, you see it completely differently.
האזינו השמים — Speak to the Heaven Inside a Person
In this week's parsha Moshe Rabbeinu says האזינו השמים ואדברה, listen, heavens, as I speak, ותשמע הארץ אמרי פי, and let the earth hear the words of my mouth.1 Sometimes you can speak to the heavens — literally, or to the heaven inside of you — but you want the earthy parts of you to hear it too.
The Apter Rav, in the sefer Ohev Yisrael, asks the obvious question. Here is Moshe at the end of his life, delivering his last address to the people. Imagine a rav who served a congregation for forty years, and now he rises for his final drasha. The shul is packed, everyone is there — and he says, "Listen, heaven. Listen, earth." Really? You gave up on the people and now you're talking to the walls?
He explains that in his final shiur Moshe was teaching every teacher, forever, how to communicate. When you speak to people, do not get stuck in their earthiness. Speak to the heaven inside of them. Everybody has a piece of heaven. Even someone who seems lost, cast away at the very edge — the Belzer Rebbe, the Sar Shalom, once said that even there, at the outermost edge of heaven, there is a piece of heaven inside him, and from there he can be picked up.
If I speak to the parts of a person where resistance lives, I will get resistance. Don't address the defenses. Speak to the שמים — to the purity of people, to the idealism of people — and then ותשמע הארץ, the earthy parts will hear it too. Aim higher, not lower.
Aim Above the Target
In aviation there is a concept called crabbing. If a plane needs to get from point A to point B, they will aim for a point beyond the target, because the winds will naturally pull the aircraft off course. Aim exactly at your destination and you land short of it. Aim higher and you arrive where you actually need to be.
In competitive swimming they say the same thing: imagine you're a fish and maybe you'll swim like a mentsch. Imagine you're a mentsch and you won't swim at all. So האזינו השמים is not unrealistic idealism. It is addressing the deepest parts of a person — parts that surface only rarely — so that you have a reference point of who you are at your very best.
The Tiger Who Said Shalom Aleichem
I once asked Rabbi Ephraim Waxman, shlita, how his boys were doing in yeshiva, how he reads the climate among the bochurim. He answered me with a parable.
There was a man who owned a zoo and needed a tiger, but tigers from Africa were terribly expensive. So he hired a Yid who needed parnassa. "Would you like to be a tiger?" "Sure, if the pay is good, I'll be anything." What doesn't a person do to put challah on the table for Shabbos and food for Sukkos? He put on the tiger suit — and he excelled. His roars, his growls, the way he paced and fought and relaxed. He became an overnight sensation. Tourists came from everywhere to see this incredible tiger, and the owner was raking it in.
A year passes. Seven o'clock at night, the last visitor is supposed to be gone, and our Jew figures the day is over. The attendant walks in. "Shalom aleichem!" And the tiger answers, "Aleichem shalom, how are you? Oy, has this been a long, hard day." What he didn't realize was that one tourist was still standing there. The man runs to the owner: "You're a ganav! You dressed a person up as a tiger. I've been coming here a whole year. I want my money back and I'm going to publicize that you're a crook." The owner says, "Relax. What happened?" "I heard the tiger say shalom aleichem!" "How long have you been coming?" "A year." "How often?" "Every week." "Did you ever hear him speak?" "Never." "So what a fool you are! He speaks one time and that cancels out a whole year of silence? אחרי רבים להטות — we follow the majority. Statistically, he's a tiger."
We laugh, because we know the zoo owner, for all his brilliance, is dead wrong. If he were really a tiger he would never say shalom aleichem — not once a year, not once in two years, not once in forty years. The very fact that he can utter those two words means that the other three hundred sixty-four days he is not a tiger either. He is a human being dressed up like one.
People judge themselves by their lowest moments. That is not a fair judgment. Judge yourself by your highest moments. If even once a year you channel something far deeper, that means it is connected to you; it is not false and it is not inauthentic. I look at the worst thing I ever did, my weakest and most desperate moment — I ate inappropriately, I spoke inappropriately — and I sum up my whole life with it. Fix it, learn from it, absolutely. But do not reduce yourself to that person.
A Debate That Lasted Two and a Half Years
To go deeper we need to open a very strange debate in the Talmud. The Gemara in Eruvin, daf yud-gimel, teaches: תנו רבנן, שתי שנים ומחצה נחלקו בית שמאי ובית הלל.2 The school of Shammai and the school of Hillel argued for two and a half years.
Now, that Jews argue is hardly news; we have been debating for four thousand years. In your own home there are probably arguments running for twenty and thirty years — lights on, lights off, blinds up, blinds down, too cold, too hot, milchigs, fleishigs, we're going out, we're not going out. That people debate for years is not the end of the world. What is fascinating here is that the Talmud records this one, that it ran two and a half years between the greatest sages of the era, and that its conclusion seems to contradict all of Yiddishkeit.
Beis Shammai and Beis Hillel were the two great schools of Torah learning that flourished around a century before the destruction of the second Beis Hamikdash, and they continued for generations. They argued about hundreds of things — whether on the first night of Chanukah you light eight candles or one. But this argument is purely philosophical, seemingly without any practical application at all. One side says: נוח לו לאדם שלא נברא יותר משנברא — it would have been preferable for a human being not to have been created than to have been created. The other says the opposite: it is preferable that he was created.
That is the debate. Not one practical detail. Should we have been created or not? You're already here! And then the Gemara tells us what happened: נמנו וגמרו — after two and a half years they took a vote and followed the majority. And the verdict? נוח לו לאדם שלא נברא יותר משנברא. It would have been better had man not been created. ועכשיו שנברא, now that he has been created, יפשפש במעשיו — let him examine and scrutinize his deeds and correct what must be corrected.
There was once a shikker I knew, a clever man who nebach fell into alcoholism. The Torah opens בראשית ברא, and the first Rashi is אמר רבי יצחק, לא היה צריך להתחיל את התורה — there was no need to begin here. So he used to say: בראשית ברא, God created the world, and Rashi comments, לא היה צריך — in my opinion, there was no need for it.
The Question That Will Not Go Away
The problem is enormous. Anyone who opens Parshas Bereishis sees that after each day of creation the Torah summarizes: וירא אלקים כי טוב. And on the sixth day, after Adam and Chava: וירא אלקים את כל אשר עשה והנה טוב מאד.3 Very good.
And then, a thousand or fifteen hundred years later, the greatest sages of Jewish history convene and say — we're not sure. Let's put it to a debate. And these were not idlers with time to burn; these were the giants of Torah, who had other things to do. Hashem holds you should be created; how do I know? He created you! And they are still deliberating, for two and a half years. Who exactly are they arguing with?
And then it goes to a vote, and the winning opinion is the one that says it would have been better not. You would think that after everything, someone would finally convince his colleagues that life is good. We say עבדו את ה' בשמחה. The Rambam writes that simcha in avodas Hashem is one of the fundamentals of Judaism — to be joyous, spirited, positive. Emunah and bitachon are all about positivity. And here the conclusion sounds crushingly negative. It isn't that this detail is wrong and that detail needs fixing. Your very existence is the problem! And that is the halacha — נמנו וגמרו. All that is left is: now that you're here, make the best of it. It reads like someone who comes to you and says, I have a miserable job, a miserable marriage, miserable in-laws, and you answer, I agree with you entirely — now make the best of it.
One could suggest that the wording itself softens it: the Gemara does not say טוב, it says נוח — from נחת, מנוחה. It would have been more restful, more serene. That is a fine observation, but we need to go deeper. And we still have to understand the other side. Everyone knows life is hard; they knew it too. What were they fighting about for two and a half years? This is a classic case where without the פנימיות, the inner dimension, you cannot begin to appreciate what these two opinions are saying.
אלוקי נשמה — The First Words of the Day
For that we turn to the first blessing of the morning, in ברכות השחר. The Gemara in Berachos, daf samech, says that when a person wakes up he says אלוקי נשמה שנתת בי טהורה היא.4 In the time of the Gemara they did not say מודה אני; they said this immediately. Today we begin with מודה אני because it contains no Name of Hashem and can be said before נטילת ידים. Then we wash, we make על נטילת ידים, one says אשר יצר, and then comes this blessing.
What does it say? אלוקי, נשמה שנתת בי טהורה היא — my God, the soul You placed within me is pure. אתה בראתה, You created it. אתה יצרתה, You formed it. אתה נפחתה בי, You blew it into me. ואתה משמרה בקרבי, You guard it within me. ואתה עתיד ליטלה ממני, and You will one day take it from me. ולהחזירה בי לעתיד לבוא, and You will return it to me in the future. כל זמן שהנשמה בקרבי, as long as the soul is within me, מודה אני לפניך — I acknowledge You, I thank You, I surrender before You.
Now look carefully, because something here is very strange. The natural order would be to establish that the thing exists before describing it. First say: the soul You gave me — You created it. Now that it exists, let me tell you what it looks like: it is pure. But that is not what we say. We say נשמה שנתת בי טהורה היא, the soul You placed in me is pure — and only afterward, אתה בראתה, You created it. Purity comes before creation. And you cannot be pure if you don't exist.
This blessing is the very first thing we say in the morning because it is, without question, the single most important thing a person needs to know each day. Before I can begin my day I need to pause and breathe — נשמה is from נשימה, breath — and tune in to who I am. If I don't know who I am, I can spend the entire day going in circles. It is a compass. It anchors me in my center, in my essential identity, and only from there do I begin navigating.
One of the most torturous experiences in life is being in a maze with no idea where you are going — and the reason is usually not that the road signs are missing. It is that I don't know who I am, so I am pulled by every instinct, every text, every pressure, every demand. By one in the afternoon a person is in complete emotional disarray. Why? Because he never took those few moments to go inward and establish his core. In exercise they call it working the abs: build a powerful center, and from there begin. If I get into my car and Google Maps asks where I want to go and I don't know, I'll just start driving and see which text comes my way — I have to go shopping, I have to go here, I have to go there. First establish where you come from and where you are going.
What It Means That He Blew It Into Me
The Alter Rebbe, the Baal HaTanya, in a discourse on Shabbos Shuvah and Nitzavim, opens this up. The Gemara in Tractate Shabbos says כל ימיו בתשובה — a person should be in teshuvah all the days of his life. What does that mean? Simply, nobody knows when his time will come, so a person should always be doing teshuvah. But if teshuvah were only repenting for wrongdoing, that's a strange blessing to give someone: sin your whole life and always apologize? It's like telling a husband or a wife, make mistakes every single day, just be sure to say you're sorry. Maybe try sometimes not to make the mistake in the first place.
So teshuvah must be something else. It says in Koheles that the spirit returns to Hashem who gave it. Return what? Why does it have to be returned?
Here is the key. אתה נפחתה בי — You blew it into me. When you blow, the הבל, the breath, first exists inside you, indistinguishable from you. I don't point and say, here is me and there is my breath. But the moment I exhale, it leaves me and becomes a separate entity with a reality of its own outside me. Today we know how real that is: the entire technology of radio and telegraph rests on the fact that an uttered word does not simply dissolve into oblivion — detect its impact and you can sit in Australia and hear what someone said in New York. And so it is written of Adam: ויפח באפיו נשמת חיים.
Which means the soul did not originate as a בריאה, as a creation. The soul originated as part of the Divine. There are two states of the soul: the soul before the blowing, and the soul after the blowing. That is why נשמה שנתת בי טהורה היא comes before אתה בראתה. Creation is stage two. Pre-creation, the soul already was — not as a creation, but as Creator.
What was it then? טהורה. The word טהירו in Aramaic means pure, and it also means light — טיהרא is the hour when the sun blazes at its height. So טהורה means the soul is pure luminescence, the light of Hashem, subsumed in His very core, part of the אין סוף. Hashem is infinite; the soul is an extension, a manifestation, a derivative of that infinity. Not separate at all.
Then אתה בראתה — You took that divinity and made it a creation. אתה יצרתה — You formed it. אתה נפחתה בי — You exhaled it into a body, and it experiences itself as having left. ואתה משמרה בקרבי — it now exists as an entity inside me. ואתה עתיד ליטלה ממני — and it will return to its source. ולהחזירה בי — and You will give it back. And therefore, because the soul comes from radical infinite love and returns to radical infinite love, מודה אני לפניך: even while it feels separate, I surrender that separateness back to its source, so that it should not remain detached even when it perceives itself as detached.
Mazal: The Root of the Soul
This root of the soul is what is called a person's מזל. The Gemara's statement אין מזל לישראל refers to constellations and planetary influences — those do not determine a Jew's life. But there is another meaning of mazal entirely: the source, the root, of one's own soul. Mazal is from נזילה, a flow, a trickling down. The root of the soul continuously trickles down into the conscious soul that dwells in the body, and the connection is never severed.
When a person suddenly has a divine flow, a thought of real teshuvah — what happened? The source of his soul sent down an extra trickle, and an awakening stirred. I don't even know why. My mazal was tickled by an arousal from above, and it reached me.
Chazal speak of voices that make announcements every day. What is the point, if nobody hears them? The answer is that your mazal hears every בת קול. Its antennas are perfectly clear; it detects everything. It is my conscious self that is blocked, so I never get the memo. There is always some trickle, and sometimes there is a greater flow, and then I begin to experience my mazal — and in that moment the two parts of my soul are literally joined.
That is the essence of teshuvah. Teshuvah is a continuous posture in life: my soul knows who it is, and therefore it is perpetually returning to its source, surrendering its separateness back to the place from which it was taken. This is the בחינת אין, the no-thingness, which is the mazal. And this, the Alter Rebbe writes, is the entire purpose of the soul's descent into this physical world — to reach a level higher even than it had in Gan Eden, basking in the radiance of the Shechinah. Gan Eden was still within the realm of בראתה. Only down here can the soul meet its true essence, the טהורה, the mazal itself. The whole reason the soul came into this coarse world is to become a baal teshuvah.
What do you mean, become a baal teshuvah? I'm FFB. He says you've got it wrong. Teshuvah means being in touch with the reality of life — that there is a separation from the Life of life, and that I am always choosing return, choosing return, choosing return. Sometimes the person who thinks his life is perfect is precisely the one deprived of the gift for which his soul came down, because he never appreciates what teshuvah is.
The Man Who Lost the Nigun
Let me offer a metaphor. There was once a man who loved music, exquisitely sensitive to it, and one day he heard a nigun. Somebody in a marketplace was playing it on a violin. It was not merely beautiful; it was life-changing. His soul danced from ecstasy. But you know how it goes — you promise yourself you will never forget it, you come home, and the melody is gone.
So he sets out to find it. He travels continent to continent, country to country, chasing every lead. I'm looking for the nigun. Everyone sings him something; everyone has beautiful melodies and ballads, all of them lovely, all of them geshmak. That's not the nigun. And he goes on and on. Sometimes the desperation is so great that he makes believe he has found it, just to calm himself down — but a few days later he knows it isn't the one. It didn't hit the spot. And people look at him like a meshuggener: there is plenty of good music in the world, just pick a song and relax. Besides music there are potato chips. There's vanilla ice cream. There are hot tubs, massages, money. But he cannot be satisfied. And then one day he walks in somewhere and hears it — and he knows instantly. That's it.
That is the story of your life. That is exactly what the Alter Rebbe is describing.
אין Does Not Mean Nothing
The neshamah originates in a place of אין. We translate אין as "nothing," but that is the wrong translation. The correct translation is "no thing" — almost the opposite meaning. Nothing is emptiness. How are you feeling? Nothing. What's going on? Nothing. Nothing drives a woman crazier than a husband who says he's feeling nothing — though between you and me, sometimes you can believe him. Sometimes he really is feeling nothing. He's been out to lunch for twenty-five years. But that's a separate shiur.
אין means no thing. The Ramban says the world was created יש מאין, something from nothing. Hashem is not nothing! What it means is: something from no-thing. That which is no thing is the source of all things. Something particular can only be the source of something particular. A bottle is a beautiful object, but it is a thing; it cannot be the source of all things. Only that which is not one defined, tangible reality — only an infinite reality — can be the mother of all reality. That is godliness. That is אין.
So the source of the neshamah is that אין, that infinity. Which means that putting the words "ego" and "soul" together is the greatest paradox there is. It is not merely that the soul has no ego; the soul and the ego are exact opposites. The soul by definition is utterly absorbed in אין. It is the light of Hashem, a derivative of Hashem. You cannot even call it an "it." Ask the soul, who are you? And the soul answers: you've got the wrong guy. The moment you ask me who I am, I'm already out of touch with myself, because the real me is אין — absorbed in no-thingness, which means in everythingness, in the totality of reality, in the space of Hashem, who has no description and no definition, the source of all love and all bliss. To call the soul a thing — never mind an ego, just a thing — is already a death sentence on its power.
So: נשמה שנתת בי טהורה היא, before You even created it. It was there before creation, as אין, as complete אין סוף, absorbed in the eternal bliss and goodness and love of Hashem.
The Original Trauma of Existence
However — and it is a very big however — the soul did not remain there. How do I know? Because I'm here. I experience myself as a form. I have an ego, and I have insecurities, and I have anxiety, and I have fear, and above all I have separateness.
What happened? אתה בראתה. You took this divinity, this אין סוף, and made it a בריאה. Still a divine soul, but a creation. Then יצרתה, it is formed. Then נפחתה בי. And what happens when you blow? The breath leaves you. Now — one second. I am אין סוף. How can anything leave Hashem? When I exhale, the breath leaves me because my mouth occupies a limited space. But you cannot leave Hashem. So ויפח באפיו means it did not really leave Him; it perceives itself as having left Him. The breath of the soul experiences itself as outside the Source.
That moment is the greatest traumatic moment in all of existence. There is nothing greater. From no-thing you suddenly became a thing. From אין I became יש. From being utterly infinite, with no ego and no self outside of Hashem, suddenly I am a self. That leap is the most radical transformation that will ever occur.
And it had to be that way. My soul, in order to be a soul, cannot feel that it is still in the Source — otherwise it never becomes separate at all. The whole purpose is to have a soul that animates a body and an animal consciousness, eighty-six billion neurons, sixty trillion cells, tissue and organs and limbs and bones, every molecule and atom, until it all becomes a being called נשמה בגוף, with a name and an identity, who now has to figure out his life. In the Source nobody is figuring out his life; let Hashem figure out His life, I'm just part of Him. Here I become a separate thing.
And it is precisely at this moment that the soul can so easily forget the song.
Looking for a Song
So now the soul goes searching for a song, and the body and the animal soul step in with suggestions. There's kugel. There's kishke. There are potato chips. There's making money, getting attention, getting validation, becoming the tzaddik or the tzaddeikes of the generation, becoming the biggest baalas chesed in the tri-state area. This person should like me, that person should like me. It can even be dressed in spiritual and religious garments. But I am looking for validation for a breath that experiences itself as severed from its source, gasping for oxygen. It is really looking for the song.
The animal soul and the body come to the divine soul and say: we have a beautiful life for you. And they teach the divine soul how to survive and function in a world where it can feel safe. But what is the anxiety of the soul? It is looking for the original song. It knows this is not the nigun. It is nice to get attention. It is nice to be successful. It is nice when people like you. It is nice to be a good man or a good woman, and nice to have every blessing in the world. Genuinely nice. But the soul knows there is an essential nigun at the core of everything, and the only music that touches its heart space is the music of ביטול, of ego death, of returning to טהורה — because that is who I really am.
Here is where crises in life — and I say this with enormous sensitivity — become a blessing. If my life is functioning perfectly, I never have to go to those places. The potato chips work. I don't mean to pick on potato chips; if you enjoy them, gezunterheit, eat them. It could be ice cream, milkshakes, whatever it is. The point is that when the outer stuff works, I can numb the need for the song, because the urge never becomes unbearable.
When a person is gifted with parts of his life beginning to disintegrate — I'm trying so hard, why isn't this working, why isn't that working, especially when the people closest to me are not giving me the feedback I expected — two things can happen. Either I dig deeper into my shell, cover myself up further, distract myself more, work harder, sleep less, go into overdrive, making sure it is business as usual so I never have to feel the yearning. Or Hashem gifts me with something greater and does not let me do that. קול דודי דופק פתחי לי.5 Open up, open up. You were not made to be closed. You were created to crack open.
Why Cracking Open Is So Hard
But cracking open is hard, because I have spent my whole life constructing a palace of cards, a functional image. And not out of malice — there was nothing sinister in it. It was completely innocent, even idealistic. It was the best thing I knew how to do: survive in a world of sharks in the only way I understood. My coping mechanisms served me very well. Some people do it in ugly ways; some do it in beautiful, kind, religious, even spiritual ways.
I'm not preaching to you here as a lecturer. I know this from my own life. There is often nothing mean about it at all. It is innocent, and in a sense it is God's own story — this was the best way I had to make sense out of life. We want to survive. We need to survive. The soul no longer knows who it really is, because remember, ויפח, it experiences itself as outside. So the body and the animal soul say: I'll give you an identity. What you really want is for people to like you. What you really want is this kind of success, that kind of success. And they build me up in the way they know how, and I achieve it — and I spend my entire life circling my own core without ever meeting my deepest אין.
It goes deeper still. Imagine standing at the edge of a cliff. It is terrifying; nobody wants to be there. So suppose I decide I must avoid that image at all costs, and I will therefore do everything in my life to deny that I am standing at the edge — even if that means denying my own truth entirely. If I carry a deep inner shame at my core that I cannot even look at, certainly I don't want anyone else to see it. So I spend my whole life avoiding internal spaces I never made peace with, and my entire existence becomes organized around avoidance. And if that is what happens, I can never really be open, and I can never really be free. And it is all subconscious; I am not doing it deliberately.
The reason is that until I am willing to face the original trauma of existence — the separateness of the I from the Infinite — I am not ready to face the story of my own life.
Life puts obstacles in front of us that are really reminders that I need to crack open. If I have none of them, if my life runs perfectly, that can be a beautiful blessing — and it can also be the profound antithesis of a blessing, because I may remain inside my shell my entire life, speaking to people and to myself from behind a mask without even knowing I'm wearing one. Fortunate, sometimes, is the person whom reality forced to crack open, as it forced me. It usually comes through deep and unexpected ways, peeling one layer after another after another, until none of the coping mechanisms work anymore. And in that moment we are finally open enough for the mazal to send down a trickle and say: you're looking for a different nigun.
Four Litmus Tests
What does that place look like? It isn't supposed to look like anything. It is full presence, with no defense mechanisms whatsoever. I am not entangled in my cobwebs, my insecurities, my fear of being better or worse than other people. I don't even have to tell stories about myself. Your antennas are pure, and in the simplest terms you are a navi — you are channeling the energy Hashem is flowing through you.
How do you know you're touching it? There are four tests.
The first is deep regulation without urgency and without anxiety. There is no ego there. I don't have to prove myself to you. I'm not better than you and not worse than you. I never have to say anything in order to cover something up. I don't manipulate, I don't exploit, I'm not busy judging myself or anyone else, and I'm not busy telling stories. There is no narrator inside my head supplying hypervigilant commentary on every person and every event. You know that guy in your brain? He doesn't stop. Here there is no more need for control, because you are completely comfortable in your space — your space is His space.
The second is the feedback of the people closest to you. People are on all kinds of healing journeys today, and they ask how to tell whether they are genuinely healing or merely descending further into ego and toxicity. Watch the people who actually live with you, who care for you, who love you and know you. If the whole world is telling you how unbelievable you are but your own spouse and children are saying they have never seen such a narcissist — pause. They are presumably not all corrupt and crazy. If your own immediate family is completely turned off, something is very strange. And this happens, and happens, and happens, which is why I'm saying it. When those closest to you say, wow, we can see how you're working on yourself — that is an enormous sign.
The third is whether your healing is putting you at odds with the Shulchan Aruch. Halacha is Hashem's blueprint for alignment. The moment my healing tells me I can adjust this halacha and that halacha — I have a new god and a new religion — then know that you are on an ego trip. You need healing. We all need healing. But don't canonize it. If you were genuinely channeling the Source, it would follow halacha; it could not possibly be at odds with it. You would not discard the laws of tznius, the laws of yichud, the laws of relationships, the laws of Shabbos and Yom Tov. If you were really channeling, you would understand that this is Hashem's blueprint.
The fourth is that you feel more humble and more of an אוהב ישראל, not more arrogant and more judgmental. When I start feeling that everybody is sick, everybody is traumatized, and I'm the only one who has emerged — a world of small consciousnesses waiting for me to enlighten them — I am finished. The higher you climb, the humbler you become. When you go to אין there is no ego. Ego is easing God out. In אין there is no judgment and no need to judge; you are there to bring out the best in yourself and the best in others.
And underneath all of them is a certain calmness that hits the spot — not a calmness because I've decided to be calm, or because Hashem wants me to be בשמחה so get out of my life, I am now בשמחה. It is an inner regulation, because your soul just heard the song. It is almost breathtaking. And it is not a calm that comes from having nothing to do or from having no pain. Hashem Himself is in pain from the pain of the world: עמו אנכי בצרה.6 When you are in אין you still have pain — perhaps deeper pain, because you now feel the pain of the Shechinah. It is not less pain. And yet within the pain your heart stays completely open, because you sense the song.
Teshuvah as a Posture
So the Baal HaTanya says: that is all teshuvah. Of course כל ימיו בתשובה — there is nothing else to life but teshuvah. Teshuvah does not mean I am bad, I am a sinner. Sometimes teshuvah repairs a specific failing, but the real teshuvah is the posture of the soul.
It consists of two recognitions. First, that I experience fragmentation and separation every single moment, because אתה בראתה, יצרתה, נפחתה — so the natural experience of life is that I am separate and I feel it. Second, that I do not have to remain that way; I can take the step that brings me back. I cannot heal what I refuse to acknowledge. So one half of teshuvah is feeling the pain of perceived detachment, and the other half is knowing I need not stay detached. It is knowing that I am homesick, and that I can go home. מסירות נפש means surrendering the separateness to the Source, and that is the most powerful posture available to a human being.
So you got angry at someone. You're judging him. You're upset at yourself. You're in guilt, in shame, in anxiety, overwhelmed, with a hundred things to do and no feeling of אין whatsoever. Fine — acknowledge it. But instead of letting the anxiety take you over and become an isolated story — this person is driving me crazy, this person is driving me crazy, and they probably are — pause, breathe, and ask what you really, deeply need. What is the pain at the root of all the pain? The truth is: I want my nigun. The soul wants the nigun, because the soul is the music. The soul is אין. The soul is אלוקות.
And notice something eternal about life: no human being in history has ever experienced real bliss — not manufactured bliss, of which there is plenty — in the presence of ego. Only in ego death can you experience all the bliss in the world. Why? Because the greatest anxiety a human being can carry is knowing that he is lying. And worse: knowing that he is a lie.
Here is the deal. The ego knows, deep down, that it is a lie. It knows it does not exist. So I can make my ego as magnificent and successful as I like, and at its DNA level there will be one word: anxious. Because deep down it knows it does not exist and you are only pretending it does. I found this in my own life: the more success, the more anxiety. Why? Because the ego knows the truth. You're laminating me, painting a beautiful portrait of me, hanging me up everywhere — it won't help. You are asserting something that is false at its core, and it knows. You will never get serenity or bliss out of a lie. The nervous system detects the truth. The only truth that brings a person to real internal happiness is when the soul hears its nigun again.
עבד ה' — The Last Two Words About Moshe
The Rambam writes that Moshe Rabbeinu was the most perfect human being who ever lived. And how does the Torah sum up his life? וימת שם משה עבד ה'.7 Moshe died — who was he? A servant of God. Really? You can't say anything nicer than that? Anybody can be a servant.
But that was precisely Moshe Rabbeinu. Because he was so talented and so complete, everything he had he could surrender in an instant. He was עבד ה'. He was never distracted and never separated. He always knew who he was, anchored in his deepest core — and the deepest core is אין. That is the mazal.
Your mazal sees everything. It knows. It hears. And when it generates a trickle of consciousness down into the soul in the body, that is what every awakening is. You're sitting on your couch, or walking down the street, and something feels off — that is the source of your soul sending a small message through a tiny pipe we call a neuron, firing up and saying: that's not your song. You're not looking for that song. It's a temporary distraction, a number, a detour.
And I answer: fine, I'll find a better song. I'll get a better song. I go to my phone, I go here, I go there, I get busy, I work, I numb myself. I get it. But the mazal I cannot numb.
Shabbos: When Hashem Does Teshuvah
Now here is something extraordinary. It is written in sefarim that שבת has the same letters as תשב — and תשב is teshuvah. So who is the very first one to do teshuvah? Who models teshuvah for all of existence? Hashem. All of His "parts" were sent outward. And when does He do teshuvah? On Shabbos.
What could it possibly mean that Hashem does teshuvah? Is He regretting creating the world? Sometimes, looking around, it might seem that way. But it is a far deeper teshuvah. The entire world is essentially God projecting outward — ואתה נפחתה בי, the breath left the mouth, and the world feels separate. Shabbos is when Hashem brings everything back to its source. Teshuvah, as we have seen, is not necessarily about sins at all. It is the soul recognizing that it descended and feels fragmented and separate, and bringing itself back — surrendering any separateness of my will before the one Will that is truly mine, my nigun.
And that is why the עשרת ימי תשובה and Yom Kippur were given even to complete tzaddikim. What are they supposed to do? I'm fine — well, ask your wife; better yet, ask your shviger. But seriously: what is a perfect tzaddik meant to do on Yom Kippur? The answer is that this is the entire purpose of a human being. If you are a tzaddik, you do more teshuvah, not less. Teshuvah is not looking in the mirror and cataloguing yesterday's aveiros. A tzaddik can honestly say, I tried to live in alignment, and if I did something wrong I'll repair it. But a real tzaddik feels the fragmentation more acutely, not less, and therefore his urge for teshuvah is more powerful.
As I said last week: don't do teshuvah because you hate yourself. Do teshuvah because you love yourself. Teshuvah is not because I am evil. Teshuvah is because essentially I am in a place of אין. Teshuvah is: I don't even want to be a thing. I want to be no thing. I am an extension of the Divine, and that is the truth of who I am. And yet all of life pulls me away from it — and that is precisely the purpose of creation.
This is the whole idea behind the first blessing of the day. I know where I come from, and I know where I am going back. Now I get to choose it. We come from radical love, we return to radical love, and in this world we get to choose radical love. What a gift. As in the metaphor I used last week: the wave rises out of the ocean and returns to the ocean, and for a few moments — or a few decades — it takes on the form of a wave. The worst thing the wave can do to itself in those moments is detach itself from the ocean and live a tortured life. Even while I am a wave, with a form, with everyone photographing me and enjoying me at the beach — I am the ocean.
Teshuvah is knowing that at my deepest core I have no points to score, no tallies to keep, nobody to repay. All of that is the anxiety generated by the animal soul's need to establish itself as a separate reality, negotiating and fighting, where the one who dies with the most toys wins. What if I could let all of it go and recognize that what I actually want is real דביקות with the Source? And even if right now I feel nothing of the sort — fine, that too is part of the separation — at least I refuse to sink further into denial and distract myself with songs that are alien to me.
So Shabbos is the day when Hashem, כביכול, does teshuvah, when the whole world returns to its source. That is why Shabbos is holy and the world becomes a holy place: it is in a state of teshuvah. Shabbos is the day of אין.
Davening: A Small Shabbos Every Day
The Alter Rebbe continues: this is why we daven every day. Davening is the small Shabbos of each day. To reach Shabbos, every day needs a little Shabbos inside it; every day's tefillah carries a glimmer of the light of Shabbos. And so, he writes, this is what a person should do at the time of prayer — let himself release everything he is enmeshed in, so as to experience the serenity of Shabbos. Can I let go of the anxious thoughts that pull me away from connection? That is the preparation for Shabbos, when the entire day is in the state of teshuvah.
Here is the practical embodiment of everything we have said. Every single day a person owes it to his soul to give himself a taste of Shabbos. It does not mean I have no responsibilities. It does not mean the cleaning help is doing a wonderful job, or that the to-do list is short. It means that before I get enmeshed — bombarded by a hundred thoughts about people and events, about yesterday and tomorrow, about everything except one thing: presence — I stop. דביקות means presence.
What if, in the deepest place, what I really want is the surrender of ego into אין סוף? That is the nigun of my soul. I don't want to be defensive. I don't want to be right. I don't want this person to validate me — not because there isn't a part of me that wants it. There is. I do want this person to apologize. He wronged me. I'm anxious. You made a comment and I'm hurt and I'm feeling it. Can I sit with all of that? I don't have to run from any of it.
The mistake people make is hearing this and concluding, right, this is who I am — and an hour later a text arrives from someone close to you and you are completely freaking out. So if you're so אין, why are you freaking out? We have to be honest. I can sit with all my emotions and say: right now the two-year-old in me was triggered. Yes, there is a part of me that is still two years old. Welcome. That's why I'm cute. And there's a part that's three, and a part that's four. With every birthday we keep all the previous years; I am still one and two and three and four. Blessed is the person who can be an adult and still hold the child inside him. That is teshuvah — I can hold all these parts.
Yes, I'm overwhelmed. I don't even know when this class is going to end. I just wanted a little inspiration for Yom Kippur because I'm having a blah, boring day, and I just heard who's coming for Sukkos, and I'm in a terrible mood, and I really don't want to go to the sheva brachos tonight or the bar mitzvah tonight, and if I remember what happened three months ago — whoa, whoa, whoa. Breathe. I can hold all of it and watch it, without getting sucked in and lured, because I am not two years old right now. And maybe I'm even right. He should apologize, he did this, he said that — and now I'm litigating it in my head, and two hours later I'm drowning in anxiety.
What is the solution? Don't argue with your anxiety. Anyone who argues with anxiety becomes more anxious. I promise you; been there, done that. Your anxiety is more powerful than every argument in the world, and all it wants is to keep you inside the loop. Argue with yourself, and then argue with everybody else. We don't argue with anxiety. We watch it, we observe it, we can even have compassion for it. But we don't get lured into its loop, over-identify with it, and end up worshipping it.
And maybe there is something to be done about it. Maybe there is a conversation to be had. Maybe I need to process it internally. Maybe I simply have to sit with the discomfort and not bypass it. When you sit with it without judging it and without being defined by it, you can then ask the deeper question: what is my deeper pain? And you will always find that the deeper pain is attachment. I want to be connected. I don't want to be misunderstood, suspected, mistrusted, seen the wrong way. And if you go deeper still: of course you want to be attached — you want to be attached to the Source of everything. Deep down I don't even want to be an I. I want to be one with You. And that is who you are.
Now I can ask myself the operative question: will the next thing I say, the next thing I do, the next thought I indulge, bring me closer to that attachment or further from it? What usually happens is that I get distracted and overwhelmed, and then I start hunting for things I never actually wanted.
So every day has a mini Shabbos in it. There will be plenty of anxiety. Hold it, have compassion for it, and then release its control. Can you lean into the fact that your soul is in the womb of Hashem? He is holding it. He sees you. You are inside. You are אין. טהורה היא. You are a piece of light. Can you look at yourself and say, I am Hashem's light? Me? No, not me, I messed up — here we go again. Of course; a part of me needs to remind me while I'm learning that I'm messed up, and then it brings up what happened on Rosh Hashanah, and then the day after, and then a year before. All of it to keep me away from real connection. I can't fight it. I can hold it. And then I can choose, without fighting the other parts, to tune into a deeper place, where I tell myself: I am now going to be present with my deepest truth, which is אין, which is Shabbos, which is תשב, which is נשמה שנתת בי טהורה היא — where all I want is my nigun. The song of infinity, the song of oneness, the song of ביטול. The song in which I am not separate, I never was separate, and I never will be separate. And to let that flush through my nervous system and through my body. The thoughts will keep coming, and I will keep looking at them and leaning again into trust, into surrender, into faith, into a heart space of love. I'm safe. I'm fine. I never really left. I am now choosing not merely to be homesick, but to identify that I am homesick and to take an actual step toward connection, toward love, toward authenticity.
נוח לו לאדם שלא נברא — Now Read It Again
Now we can return to our Gemara, and you will see this was never an argument about whether life is a curse.
נוח לו לאדם שלא נברא. We are all שלא נברא! That is stage one of the soul — טהורה — and אתה בראתה is only stage two. So one opinion says: נוח, it is far more comfortable, far more מנוחה, for a person in the state of לא נברא. If we could remain there, and if we return there, there is incomparably more serenity, more bliss, more joy, more ecstasy than in שנברא.
Because the need for ego is a trauma need. All our needs for ego are trauma needs. In recent years I have not seen a single machlokes — I don't mean a legitimate disagreement, I mean a real machlokes, where people stop talking, where there is hatred — in a community or in a family that was not rooted in trauma. Not one. You speak to the people and they are partial trauma victims, all of them trying to survive, each one convinced that if he stops fighting he will be killing himself. That is literally the trauma response of someone who does not know who he is.
נוח לו לאדם שלא נברא. If you could feel for one split second what it is to be לא נברא — that is מנוחה. That is Shabbos. I never have to be defensive again.
In the ego world that makes no sense. What do you mean I shouldn't be defensive? You just criticized me. You just attacked me. Somebody defamed me on social media. Someone called me about exactly this, because he had seen that the same thing had been done to me some time ago and wanted to know how I handle the anxiety. And how am I supposed to tell him — this? Because this is the only real answer: לא נברא. If I am trying to establish myself as an identity, then every arrow that comes at me lands, and my whole life can become a torture chamber — he said this, she said that, they wrote that email. I know it, because I lived there. I'm not telling you I've arrived; baruch Hashem, I have plenty of my own work to do, כל ימיו בתשובה. But I understand the posture very well, because I lived in it. It's called survival. You're swimming among sharks, so you had better be a shark. You're not swimming among benevolent whales. Either you eat them or they eat you, so eat first. It makes complete sense — and it is a trauma response.
The other opinion holds נוח לו לאדם שנברא יותר משלא נברא: since Hashem wanted the נברא, that itself is better and more comfortable. And what is the halacha? נמנו וגמרו, נוח לו לאדם שלא נברא יותר משנברא. Ultimately, the deepest serenity available to a human being is to experience the שלא נברא far more than the נברא. That is the נוח.
ועכשיו שנברא — but God wanted me to be created. So which is it? It is נוח to be שלא נברא, and yet He wants me created. That is exactly what teshuvah is. The separateness is not my need. You know whose need it is? Hashem's. My need is ביטול. Ego death. That is what I really need, and that is what you really need, and if you knew yourself you would know it. My heart wants only to be open and to channel pure authenticity. That's my song. I want to play my song. Rabbi Yehuda HaLevi says אני כנור לשיריך — I am a harp for Your melodies. My soul is a harp for the melody of the אין סוף. That is what it is, and that is what it wants to play, and that is the space I want to live in 24/7. Peel away the kelipos, get behind the coping mechanisms, and that is all there is.
You want to defame me? Whom are you defaming? When you are לא נברא, you didn't defame anybody. That is what I tried to explain to the man who called: find yourself, and don't spend the next year of your life going to war, because that war will devour your marriage and your relationships. He said, wow, that's a big madreiga. I told him it isn't a madreiga at all — it's self-respect. The only One who has to know that you were pure is Hashem. If Hashem knows you were pure, trust me, that is more than enough. Yes, but, but, but — I understand the buts; I'm out there too. But that is the truth. If Hashem knows you're pure, you're good to go, and every authentic person will eventually know it too. And if Hashem doesn't know you're pure, then you have far bigger problems than social media.
The Gemara relates something beautiful along these lines. Rav Shimon bar Yochai came to the shiur and Rabbi Akiva seated him in the back of the room, and he was deeply upset. Rabbi Akiva said to him: Shimon, it is enough for you that I and your Creator see you. Notice the wording — I and your Creator. Hashem sees you, and that is the core of everything. But in life you also need at least one human being who truly sees you. I don't think you need more than one. People who had one person who saw them are the people who came to see themselves.
So why do I feel separate at all, if I don't need it? Because He needs it. He desired אדיר רבתא בתחתונים; He wanted teshuvah; He wanted that I, in my separateness, should choose connection. I cannot choose it if I am not separate. A fetus in the womb is not choosing its mother; it has no choice. Once the umbilical cord is cut, now there is an avodah of choosing mommy — and some of your children are working through that at various stages, choosing mommy and defying mommy. Mark Twain said that when he was nine his father was a genius, when he was nineteen his father was a moron, and now that he's twenty-nine his father gives such brilliant advice — it's amazing how much the old man learned in ten years. We go through stages. And it is precisely the separateness that makes the entire avodah of teshuvah possible.
Yom Kippur: שבת שבתון
Yom Kippur is called שבת שבתון, the Shabbos of Shabbosos. The Baal HaTanya explains that it is so powerful a Shabbos that all the other Shabbosos are like weekdays relative to it. That is why it is the central day of teshuvah.
What is the experience of Yom Kippur? It is the day when the soul experiences in its heart space the deepest expression of the nigun — when Hashem, so to speak, opens His own heart space so that the soul's heart space can feel the אין with full force.
That is why Yom Kippur opens with כל נדרי: all the vows, all the promises we have made to ourselves, all the shackles that hold us back, we release — because none of them ever came from אין. They came from fear and from the ego's craving for security. And it ends with נעילה. We usually explain נעילה as the gates of heaven about to close, so daven quickly. But there is a deeper meaning: at that hour the gates are closed and you are inside. Like the חדר ייחוד of the chosson and kallah at the end of the chuppah. That is the climax of Yom Kippur, and when we call out שמע ישראל, ברוך שם, and ה' הוא האלקים seven times, it is the opening of the heart space that says: all I want is You.
So Yom Kippur is the ultimate experience of teshuvah, a שבת שבתון out of which the entire year grows — the posture in which the soul never betrays itself, and from the moment I wake up I know who I am and therefore how I want to live today.
And once I have grasped what teshuvah is at its core — not only the tree but the forest — all the details become manifestations of it. Of course I want to show up at every moment with an open heart and with presence. Before I open my mouth to my child, to my spouse, to anybody, I ask: will this bring me more attachment or more detachment? Will this help me find my song or numb me from my song? Before I put something into my mouth, the way I carry myself twenty-four hours a day — it is not because I'm on a high level. It's because I'm in touch with myself. If I know deep down that there is one song that will give me real bliss, real connection, real attachment, then I also know that every other song is a blockage, a number, a distraction, a dissociation. From that presence I can look at the next word, the next thought, the next action, and ask whether it takes me into that deeper place of connection or is just another number. I may have a great deal going on. I can hold all of it — and then choose the posture of teshuvah.
May you all be blessed with an amazing year, a good year, a year of abundance, and a year of redemption.
Sources
- Devarim 32:1 האזינו השמים ואדברה ותשמע הארץ אמרי־פי׃ ↩
- Eruvin 13b ↩
- Bereishis 1:31 וירא אלקים את־כל־אשר עשה והנה־טוב מאד ויהי־ערב ויהי־בקר יום הששי׃ ↩
- Berachos 60b ↩
- Shir HaShirim 5:2 אני ישנה ולבי ער קול ׀ דודי דופק פתחי־לי אחתי רעיתי יונתי תמתי שראשי נמלא־טל קוצותי רסיסי לילה׃ ↩
- Tehillim 91:15 יקראני ׀ ואענהו עמו־אנכי בצרה אחלצהו ואכבדהו׃ ↩
- Devarim 34:5 וימת שם משה עבד־י-ה-ו-ה בארץ מואב על־פי י-ה-ו-ה׃ ↩
