Sukkos: The Return of the Clouds of Glory - The Vilna Gaon Revolutionizes Sukkos

Before you begin

Why does Sukkos, alone among the Yamim Tovim, omit the Torah's language of Hashem resting His Shechinah, and what are we really commemorating when we sit in the Sukkah?

Six questions. Rav Meir Simcha notices Sukkos alone lacks לשכן שמו שם. The Tur's answer that Sukkos is timed for recognizability raises its own puzzle. Why commemorate the Ananei HaKavod and not the man or the be'er? Why is Sukkos called Chag HaAsif in Mishpatim and Ki Sisa but Chag HaSukkos only in Re'eh? Why does the Midrash list the Anan last, and why buy lulav before Yom Kippur but build the Sukkah only after?

Two kavanos. Sitting in the Sukkah without intending to fulfill the mitzvah accomplishes nothing, and the bracha, per the Mishnah Berurah, does not supply that kavanah. A second kavanah is required too: per Rashi, Targum, the Mizrachi and the Shulchan Aruch, the Sukkos of the Midbar mean Ananei HaKavod, not actual booths, and one must have that specifically in mind.

The Gaon's turn. The Jewish people do not celebrate miracles. The Vilna Gaon on Shir HaShirim traces how the Ananei HaKavod departed after the cheit ha'egel, remained absent even after Yom Kippur's forgiveness on the tenth of Tishrei, and returned only when the Mishkan's building began on the fifteenth. Sukkos marks that return, not the original miracle.

Ratzon, not kaparah. Rabbeinu Yonah teaches that atonement is not the goal; one wants Hashem to want him again. אתה בחרתנו is Pesach, אהבת אותנו is Shavuos, ורצית בנו is Sukkos — the restored relationship, greater than before, is והיית אך שמח's joy.

Where it lands. Sukkos is Tishrei because we mark the return, not the miracle; Chag HaAsif becomes Chag HaSukkos only after the egel. Women, per the Chasam Sofer, were never expelled from the Anan, so Tosafos's question dissolves. Since Sukkos reenacts building the Mishkan, the Sukkah carries kedushas Mikdash, explaining לשכן שמו שם's absence and the ceremonious leave-taking Rav Hutner describes, culminating in Simchas Torah's tikkun for the egel.

We Do Not Celebrate Miracles: The Ratzon of Sukkos

Six Questions on the Yom Tov of Sukkos

There is an extraordinary observation of Rav Meir Simcha of Dvinsk on Parashas Re'eh, in the parasha of the Yamim Tovim. The Torah says, וזבחת פסח לה' אלקיך צאן ובקר במקום אשר יבחר ה' לשכן שמו שם.1 You bring your korbanos on Pesach — where? In the place Hashem selected. Selected for what? To rest His Shechinah there. And what place is that? Yerushalayim. Fine. Then comes the Yom Tov of Shavuos: again, the place Hashem selects to rest His Shechinah there. And then comes the Yom Tov of Sukkos, and the Torah says only, "in the place Hashem selects." Selects to do what? It doesn't say. By Pesach, לשכן שמו שם. By Shavuos, לשכן שמו שם. By Sukkos, the Torah omits it entirely. That is question number one.

Question number two belongs to the Tur. We sit in the Sukkah to commemorate the Ananei HaKavod. When did Hashem place us in the Ananei HaKavod? When He took us out of Mitzrayim, on the fifteenth of Nisan. So we have a logistical problem. We have been saying Selichos for weeks, we had Rosh Hashanah, the Aseres Yemei Teshuvah, Yom Kippur — we are standing in Tishrei. Why are we commemorating something that happened six months earlier? The Tur famously answers that if we would sit in the Sukkah in Nisan, it would not be recognizable that we are doing it for the mitzvah; the weather is pleasant, and people would say we simply moved outdoors to enjoy the spring. So we wait for the rainy season.

And we certainly get what we asked for. We don't consult the American forecasters, we consult the European ones, and whenever they predict the worst weather in a decade — that's when we schedule Sukkos. The year of the great flooding in the Five Towns, it arrived precisely on the first night. Somebody showed me a photograph of himself standing in his Sukkah in flippers with water up to his knees. My own Sukkah caved in and had to be rebuilt. Perfect. We could have had this in Nisan with beautiful weather, and instead we deliberately chose the worst.

But let me ask a simple question on the Tur. Not recognizable to whom? We have beaten this like a dead horse: if you do not have kavanah that you are sitting in the Sukkah to fulfill the mitzvah, you have no mitzvah. So who is it that is supposed to recognize something here? It isn't Chanukah; there is no obvious element of persumei nissa in the parasha of Sukkah. What does it even mean that in Nisan it "wouldn't be recognizable"? Everyone sitting in that Sukkah knows exactly why he is sitting there. That is question number two, and we will return to it.

Question number three is asked by Rav Moshe Metrani, the Mabit, and by the Chida. How many great miracles were there in the Midbar? Three primary ones: the man, the be'er, and the Ananei HaKavod. Do we have a Yom Tov for the man? There is no such thing. The only commemoration of the man is that we cover the challah. And the be'er of Miriam? Nothing at all. And then, all of a sudden, for clouds we have the longest Yom Tov of the year. Clouds! Is that what occupies your attention every morning — how cloudy it's going to be? Why specifically do we commemorate the Ananei HaKavod and not the man and not the be'er?

Question number four: in Parshas Mishpatim, what is the Yom Tov of Sukkos called? Chag HaAsif, the festival of the ingathering — when everything that lay drying in the fields all summer is gathered in. And in Parshas Ki Sisa? Also Chag HaAsif. Not Chag HaSukkos. Then we arrive at Parshas Re'eh: חג הסכת תעשה לך.2 What happened to Chag HaAsif? Why is it Chag HaAsif in Mishpatim and Ki Sisa, and Chag HaSukkos only in Re'eh?

Question number five: the Midrash in Shemos Rabbah lists the miracles of the Midbar. Moshe Rabbeinu saw Klal Yisrael being elevated in the Midbar and said, who has anything like what they have in the Midbar? The man, the slav, the be'er, the Mishkan, the Shechinah, kehunah, malchus — and finally the Ananei HaKavod. The question is the order. When did we receive the Ananei HaKavod? On the fifteenth of Nisan, the moment we walked out of Mitzrayim; the Anan began guiding them out of Egypt immediately. The man we did not receive until later. So why does the Midrash list the Ananei HaKavod dead last?

And question number six is my own. When should a person buy his lulav and esrog — before Yom Kippur or after? The Mateh Efraim writes that one should procure the esrog, the lulav and the hadassim before Yom Kippur, because the zechus of his machshavah to prepare for the mitzvah is considered as though he had done the act, and it will tilt the scales in his favor on Yom Kippur. I personally tend to get mine afterward, only because the man who supplies half of New York saves me the good ones and I come when he tells me to come. But halachically, the Mateh Efraim says: before. Now, that same Mateh Efraim writes that one should begin building his Sukkah immediately on Motzaei Yom Kippur, going straight from one mitzvah to the next. So why the difference? If the whole point is to add weight to your scales, why not build the Sukkah before Yom Kippur too?

Two Kavanos Without Which You Have Nothing

Before we answer any of this, there is something far more practical that must be said, and it is the most important information about the Yom Tov of Sukkos that I can give you.

How is it possible to eat in your Sukkah and have it considered as though you ate outside the Sukkah? A man sits down in a beautiful Sukkah, eats his meal, and never once thinks, "I am having kavanah to fulfill the mitzvah of Sukkah." Does he get credit for the mitzvah? I have been beating this like a dead horse for two years: if you perform a mitzvah without intending to fulfill the mitzvah, you have not fulfilled the mitzvah. So this fellow ate in the Sukkah — and, as Rav Shlomo Zalman puts it, it is as though he ate outside the Sukkah.

I said this somewhere recently and they flipped out on me, mamish flipped out. They had the principal call me. I told him, listen, this is not my religion — this is the Shulchan Aruch. I think in the end he got it. And I know what you're thinking: the bracha will cover it. It doesn't work. According to the Mishnah Berurah in siman samech, the bracha does not seem to accomplish the kavanah for you. It is certainly important that a Yid make a bracha before fulfilling the mitzvah of Sukkah — but the Mishnah Berurah is not convinced that the bracha supplies the kavanah. Isn't that something to know?

And there is a second kavanah. Besides thinking that you wish to fulfill the mitzvah, you must also think that you are sitting in the Sukkah as a commemoration of the Ananei HaKavod. Now, is it unanimous that the Sukkos of the Midbar were the Ananei HaKavod? It is a machlokes between Rabbi Eliezer and Rabbi Akiva — one holds sukkos mamash, actual booths, and one holds Ananei HaKavod. But look at Rashi on the pasuk. Who asked Rashi to weigh in on what the Sukkos were? Everyone knows it is a machlokes. Rashi's job is to give me the plain meaning of the pasuk — so why does Rashi find it necessary to tell me that בסכות הושבתי means clouds of glory? And the Targum says the same: בדיל דידעון דרייכון ארי במטלת עננא אותיבית ית בני ישראל — so that your generations should know that in the shade of clouds I settled Bnei Yisrael. Not booths. Clouds.

The Mizrachi explains that the pshat in the pasuk itself is the Ananei HaKavod. Had the Torah meant actual booths, it would have said, "so that your generations should know that in booths you sat." It says הושבתי — I settled you. How did the Ribono Shel Olam settle us? That implies clouds of glory, not huts that we built with our own hands. And the Shulchan Aruch paskens like Ananei HaKavod. Which means that a person who sits down and thinks, "I am commemorating the actual booths of the Midbar," has, according to the Shulchan Aruch, not thought the right thought. The Bach adds that one should also think that he is commemorating the Sukkos of the Midbar.

So the two things you must take out of this: when you sit in the Sukkah and when you sleep in the Sukkah, think, I have kavanah to fulfill the mitzvah of Sukkah, and I am doing so to commemorate the Ananei HaKavod. Can you handle that? If you don't have that kavanah, I hope you'll manage other mitzvos that day. But not Sukkah. Sukkah you will not have.

The Vilna Gaon: What We Are Really Celebrating

The Vilna Gaon on Shir HaShirim, perek alef pasuk daled, is the seminal, foundational basis for understanding the entire Yom Tov of Sukkos. It is revolutionary. There are two versions of it, and there is something about the second that comes out a bit more precisely; we will get to that.

Before I say the Gaon's words, let me add an editorial observation of my own: the Jewish people do not celebrate miracles. When a miracle occurs, we do not establish a Yom Tov to celebrate it. Do we have a Yom Tov for the fact that the column of smoke in the Beis HaMikdash rose straight up and was never blown by the wind? Picture Yidden all over the Catskills in mid-summer lighting bonfires — "What's this?" "We're celebrating the fire that went straight up in the Beis HaMikdash." Barbecues everywhere — "Why?" "Because the meat never spoiled in the Beis HaMikdash." We don't do that. A miracle is not such a stunning thing. The Ribono Shel Olam created the system; He can change the system whenever He wishes.

Here is what happened. When Bnei Yisrael left Mitzrayim, they were accompanied by the Ananei HaKavod. Then Hashem gave the Torah, Moshe Rabbeinu ascended Har Sinai, and he was to return after forty days. Forty days passed and there was no Moshe. The Satan painted an image in the sky of Moshe Rabbeinu lying on his deathbed, Klal Yisrael concluded that he had died, and they made the egel. Moshe comes down, sees the egel, and smashes the Luchos into smithereens. And then they look up at the sky — and the Ananei HaKavod, which was the Shechinah, is gone. It departed. And more than that: Hashem said, I am finished with you, I am going to destroy you.

So Moshe goes up for another forty days and davens for us and saves our skin. But notice what Hashem said when He relented: I will not go with you Myself; I will send a malach. And He meant it kindly — if I am among you and you sin, the punishment will be devastating. To which Moshe Rabbeinu responds, אם אין פניך הולכים אל תעלנו מזה. If You do not lead us personally, we are not budging from here. We don't want an angel. We don't want a middleman. We want You.

Moshe went up on Rosh Chodesh Elul and came down on the tenth of Tishrei with the Luchos Shniyos. Wonderful — we are forgiven. And they look up at the sky, and what do they see? Nothing. Cloudy, perhaps, but no Ananei HaKavod. Empty. They knew they had been forgiven, and they still did not have the Shechinah back.

Then, on the eleventh day of Tishrei, Moshe Rabbeinu gathered the Jewish people and commanded them regarding the melachah of the Mishkan. On the twelfth and thirteenth the people brought their nedavos, בבקר בבקר. On the fourteenth Moshe collected all the donations. On the fifteenth they began to build the Mishkan — and they lifted their eyes to the heavens and saw the return of the Ananei HaKavod.

That, says the Vilna Gaon, is Sukkos. We do not make a Yom Tov because Hashem gave us food. We do not make a Yom Tov because He gave us water. We do not make a Yom Tov because He gave us shade. We are not celebrating the miracle at all. Listen very carefully: we are celebrating that when a Jew sins and then does teshuvah, Hashem does not merely forgive him — He takes him back and loves him again as though he had never sinned, and the relationship is restored as if nothing had ever happened. Sukkos commemorates the restoration of the relationship, which was reflected in the return of the Ananei HaKavod.

Incidentally, Chanukah is precisely the same thing. There was a miracle in the Beis HaMikdash that the ner ma'aravi never went out, but roughly a century before Chanukah it had begun to be extinguished, and Klal Yisrael understood that the Shechinah had left them. When Hashem made the miracle that the ner burned for eight days, they saw that the Shechinah had returned to them as at the beginning — and they made Chanukah eight days to parallel Sukkos, because Sukkos too is the return of the Shechinah. But that is for Chanukah time.

The Avodas HaGershuni, a talmid of the Vilna Gaon, quotes this same idea with one subtle discrepancy. He also says that on the eleventh Moshe commanded them to bring the nedavos and that they brought them on the twelfth and thirteenth — but where the Gaon in Shir HaShirim says that on the fourteenth Moshe collected them, the Avodas HaGershuni says that on the fourteenth Moshe announced that they should stop bringing. Why is that version better? Because the Torah was given on Shabbos. If so, Yom Kippur of that year fell on a Tuesday; Moshe spoke to them about the nedavos on Wednesday, they brought on Thursday and Friday — and the fourteenth was Shabbos. It works out far better that on that day Moshe announced "stop bringing" than that he gathered the donations. And in fact the Gemara in Shabbos derives from that very announcement — stop bringing — the source that carrying is forbidden on Shabbos.

Kaparah Is Not the Endgame: Ratzon

Consider the three Yamim Tovim. On Pesach, Hashem selected us to be His chosen nation. On Shavuos He gave us the Torah, and in giving us the Torah He married us — the Torah is the kiddushin. And on Sukkos? On Sukkos, after Hashem threatened to destroy us for our sin, Moshe Rabbeinu obtained for us not only atonement on Yom Kippur, but something greater than kaparah. It is called ratzon.

Let me explain what ratzon is. You have a close friend. You go out together every week, you eat pizza together every Motzaei Shabbos — and he makes a wedding and doesn't invite you. How do you feel? Insulted. We're friends! And you invite everyone but me? He apologizes: I'm sorry, I wasn't thinking, I didn't have it together, I never meant it. And you make up. Erev Yom Kippur he comes to you and you say מחול לך, מחול לך, מחול לך. Then Motzaei Shabbos you call him: want to go out for pizza? No. What do you mean no? I thought you were mochel. I am mochel. So you're angry at me? I'm not angry. You want to wring my neck? Not at all. So why no pizza? Because I don't like you. I have nothing against you, I hope Hashem blesses you, you should live a long, happy life, you should win the lottery — I simply don't want to spend time with you. Make many more weddings, and please don't invite me, because I don't plan on coming. No hard feelings whatsoever. I just don't like you.

Now apply it upward. Is Yom Kippur enough? We sit in shul the entire day, we beat על חטא, we commit to everything we will improve, and the Ribono Shel Olam says: fine, I will not punish you this year. Then we come to shul to daven and we say, Hashem, I want to feel close to You. And He says, I'm not close to you, because I don't like you anymore. So You're angry? No. So You'll punish me? I will not punish you. Will I be healthy? Very healthy. Will I make money? More than last year. So why don't I feel close to You? Because you're not. Why don't I feel elevated when I daven? Because you're not elevated.

Rabbeinu Yonah teaches that kaparah is not the endgame. To be atoned for is not enough. You want Hashem to want you. You want to feel that Hashem is pleased with you, that He desires your tefillah, that He wants your mitzvos, that He likes you. He writes that one should daven that Hashem wipe away one's sins like a cloud and one's iniquities like a thick cloud, and that Hashem should want him and desire him and be entreated by him as though he had never sinned — as we find by Eliyahu, who asked to be entreated by Hashem. It is entirely possible, says Rabbeinu Yonah, that a man's aveirah is atoned, that he is cleansed and redeemed from suffering, that there is no gezeirah hanging over him at all — remember last year, that difficult year before Yom Kippur? — and yet ואין לה' חפץ בו. Hashem does not want him. He does not want his mitzvos, He does not want his tefillos. And are tzaddikim content with that? Never. The desire of the righteous, the greatest of all successes in this world, is to find favor in the eyes of Hashem.

If I were to ask you what success in this world is — is it honor? Money? None of the above. Is it doing mitzvos? That is a form of success, but it is not the greatest. The greatest success in this world is that Hashem should want you. And Rabbeinu Yonah says that from the ratzon of Hashem comes eternal life and a certain light that encompasses all sweetness. It is hard to identify and hard to quantify — a spiritual sensation that the Ribono Shel Olam desires you. As Chazal say, אין לנו אלא הארת פניך.

Which perek of Tehillim is the perek of teshuvah? Perek nun alef. After Dovid HaMelech says, wash me thoroughly from my sin, he says: do not cast me away. What does he mean? He means, I know You have atoned for my sin and You will not punish me — but don't throw me out. I want to feel close to You. Then he asks that the joy of Your salvation be returned to him, that the Ruach of HaKadosh Baruch Hu rest upon him as at the beginning. And then, listen carefully: ורוח נדיבה תסמכני — support me with Your generous spirit. I am not truly deserving that I should find favor in Your eyes, that You should love me and desire me and show me Your wonders. But surely, Ribono Shel Olam, You possess such generosity of spirit that even though I do not deserve it, You will shower me with Your illuminating countenance anyway.

So let us be clear. Yom Kippur we would call the day of selichah and mechilah. Is that the endgame? It is a very good thing not to have a dirty soul. It is a wonderful thing to have no punishment looming, no onshim hanging over you; you breathe easier. But it is not the greatest hatzlachah. The greatest hatzlachah is להפיק רצון מה' — that Hashem should want you.

And now hear the Vilna Gaon. אתה בחרתנו מכל העמים — that is Pesach. אהבת אותנו — the marriage of Shavuos. ורצית בנו — ratzon, which comes only after one has sinned against another and they have made up. If you had to capture the Yom Tov of Sukkos in two words, it is ורצית בנו. That is why the Torah says by Sukkos והיית אך שמח, a joy stated by no other Yom Tov — because on Sukkos we experienced the ritzuy of HaKadosh Baruch Hu, and that is the greatest success and the greatest brachah in life. And it exists only because of Hashem's supernatural middos. Human nature is that if someone crosses you, insults you, hurts you, and then apologizes, and you forgive him — is it ever quite the same again? Usually not. Can it be? Yes. But by the Ribono Shel Olam it is not merely the same; it is even greater than before. אהבה רבה אהבתנו ה' אלקינו — when You took us out of Mitzrayim. חמלה גדולה ויתרה חמלת עלינו — after the cheit ha'egel, when You took us back closer than ever. That is the joy of Sukkos.

The Answers Unfold

With this, the questions dissolve one after another.

Why do we celebrate Sukkos in Tishrei rather than Nisan? The answer is now obvious: we never celebrated the miracle to begin with. The Ananei HaKavod of Nisan is not what we are marking. We are marking their return, and their return took place in Tishrei.

Why is it called Chag HaAsif in Parshas Mishpatim and again in Parshas Ki Sisa? Because at that point that is all it was — the festival of the ingathering. Why in the world would anyone sit in a Sukkah then? To celebrate the miracle of the clouds of glory? We don't make Yamim Tovim for miracles. There was no Chag HaSukkos yet. Only after the cheit ha'egel, after the Ananei HaKavod departed and then returned, did we acquire a new Yom Tov. Now Chag HaAsif is also Chag HaSukkos — and that is why it appears as Chag HaSukkos only in Parshas Re'eh.

Why does the Midrash in Shemos Rabbah list the Ananei HaKavod last? The Tzaddik of Ra'anana writes that the order is not out of order at all. The man, the slav, the be'er, the Mishkan, the Shechinah, kehunah, malchus — and last of all the Anan. Because the Midrash is not listing the miracle of the Anan, which came first; it is listing the return of the Anan, and that came last.

And why buy the lulav and esrog before Yom Kippur but build the Sukkah only after? Because things must be done in their natural sequence. First you need Yom Kippur; first you must be atoned for the aveiros of the year. And then comes the Sukkah — which commemorates not only the Ananei HaKavod but the building of the Mishkan itself. Moshe announced the building on the eleventh, they brought nedavos on the twelfth and thirteenth, they stopped on the fourteenth. The Sukkah's proper moment is in the aftermath of Yom Kippur. As for accruing merit on the scales — that is a fine consideration, and that is precisely why the Mateh Efraim has you prepare your lulav and esrog beforehand. But the Sukkah belongs to the days after.

Why Women Are Exempt: A Cloud That Never Left Them

Now to a difficulty. Tosafos in Maseches Pesachim, daf 108b, asks why women are exempt from Sukkah. Women are obligated in ner Chanukah — אף הן היו באותו הנס. They are obligated in the four kosos — אף הן היו באותו הנס. So why should they not be obligated in Sukkah? A strong kashya.

And here is a second difficulty, a serious one. This entire pshat of the Vilna Gaon rests on the premise that the Ananei HaKavod departed. But the pasuk in Nechemiah says that in Your abundant mercy You did not forsake them in the wilderness; the pillar of cloud did not depart from them by day, to lead them on the way. The Navi states plainly that the Anan never ceased guiding Bnei Yisrael. According to the Vilna Gaon, it did. So this beautiful pshat does not seem to sit with the pasuk in Nechemiah.

I had this thought some thirty years ago. Tonight, as it happens, is Rabbi Akiva Eiger's yahrzeit — and there is a rule that any day on which you learn Rabbi Akiva Eiger is a good day. The minhag is to wear white on Yom Kippur, and there is also a minhag not to wear gold on Yom Kippur, because on the day we seek kaparah for the egel one does not wish to remind Hashem of the gold of the egel. Rabbi Akiva Eiger says that women may wear gold on Yom Kippur. Why? Because they did not make the egel. So may Leviim — if there are any Leviim here, put in your notification for next year.

So I thought to myself: if the women had no part in the egel, and the whole reason we celebrate Sukkos is the return of the Ananei HaKavod after the cheit ha'egel — what actually happened to the Anan? Perhaps it did not simply vanish; perhaps it expelled the Jewish people. And if it expelled them, perhaps it expelled only the men and not the women. And in fact I found that the Chasam Sofer writes exactly this: when Klal Yisrael made the egel, the Anan HaKavod remained, and it expelled the men but never expelled the women.

That resolves the pasuk in Nechemiah. The Navi says Hashem never forsook them and the Anan never departed — and that is literally true. It never departed. It only expelled the men.

And it resolves Tosafos as well. Tosafos wants women to be obligated in Sukkah because אף הן היו באותו הנס. The nes of what? Of the Ananei HaKavod. But we do not celebrate the miracle. We celebrate the return — and for the women there was no return, because they never lost it. They were sitting inside it the entire time. Sukkos, in that sense, is simply not relevant to them. It is the men who were cast out and taken back. A beautiful answer.

Daughter, Sister, Mother — and the Sukkah as Mikdash

The Meshech Chochmah takes up the teaching of Chazal that Hashem loved Klal Yisrael so greatly that He first calls us His daughter, then His sister, and finally His mother. What is that supposed to mean?

It maps onto the three Yamim Tovim. On Pesach everything was a freebie. We had descended to the forty-ninth level of tumah, we had no mitzvos, we were bare and empty-handed — and Hashem simply showered us with the geulah, with the korban Pesach, with divine revelation. We were purely the recipient and He was purely the benefactor. That is a daughter. Then comes Shavuos, which is a two-way street: we prepared ourselves, we sanctified ourselves, we came together in achdus, and Hashem descended upon Har Sinai and revealed Himself. Two partners. That is a sister. And then comes Sukkos, where we did everything — we did teshuvah, we returned to Him, we built the Mishkan, and we earned that Hashem should take us back. On Sukkos we are Hashem's mother.

The Arizal teaches that in your Sukkah you should place the shulchan in the north and the menorah in the south, exactly as they stood in the Beis HaMikdash. And the Shem MiShmuel writes in four places that the kedushah of the Sukkah is the kedushah of the Beis HaMikdash. Why should that be so? Based on everything we have said, it is obvious. The purpose of the Sukkah is not to commemorate the miracle of the Anan; it is to commemorate the return of the Shechinah — and the Shechinah rested on the Mishkan. Which means that the building of your Sukkah is the asiyas haMishkan. That is precisely why you build it after Yom Kippur, exactly as they did. And the return of the Shechinah to the Sukkah is the return of the Shechinah to the Mikdash. Therefore you arrange it like the Beis HaMikdash — because it is not a commemoration of a miracle, it is a remembering of the ratzon that Klal Yisrael achieved when they built the Mishkan in the aftermath of the cheit ha'egel.

And now return to the question of Rav Meir Simcha with which we began. On Pesach you go to Yerushalayim — the place Hashem selected to rest His Shechinah. On Shavuos you go to the Mikdash — the place Hashem selected to rest His Shechinah. And on Sukkos? On Sukkos you go to the Mikdash, the place Hashem selected to rest His Shechinah? No. On Sukkos, you know where He rests His Shechinah? In your Sukkah. That is why by Pesach the Torah says לשכן שמו שם, and by Shavuos it says לשכן שמו שם, and by Sukkos it is conspicuously absent — because on Sukkos the לשכן שמו שם is your Sukkah. Your Sukkah has kedushas Beis HaMikdash.

Simchas Torah and Taking Leave of the Mikdash

One more addition, and if it isn't amazing I'll owe you a free sefer. We build the Mishkan — which is our Sukkah — and on the fifteenth we look up to the heavens and the Shechinah has returned. Can you imagine? The Shechinah is in the Sukkah. So why do we need seven days and then Simchas Torah? Is something still missing?

Something is still missing, and it is everything. When Hashem told Moshe Rabbeinu, לך רד כי שחת עמך, go down, your people have become corrupt — Moshe asked what they had done, and Hashem said they are serving avodah zarah. What did Moshe do to the Luchos at that moment? A trick question: nothing. And when he descended and actually saw them serving the egel, what did he do to the Luchos? Again nothing. But when he saw the circles and the dancing — then he broke them.

The Seforno explains why. So they are serving avodah zarah; it is terrible, but they can do teshuvah. But now they are rejoicing over the avodah zarah. If a man sins and delights in his sin, there is no recovery from that. That is what shattered the Luchos.

So in the aftermath of the cheit ha'egel we have a Yom Kippur and we receive atonement, and we have Sukkos and Hashem wants us again — but we still have to uproot what we did completely. We have to show Hashem that this time we do not rejoice over sin; we rejoice with His Torah. That is the grand finale of the entire season. Not only Yom Kippur, not only the ratzon of Sukkos, but Simchas Torah — where we dance in circles once again, but now the circles are around HaKadosh Baruch Hu and His Torah and not around an egel. That is the full culmination and the tikkun for the cheit ha'egel.

And one final point, this time for real. When you finish with your lulav and esrog, what do you do? The lulav gets burned, the esrog becomes jam. Do you kiss the esrog goodbye? Of course not, however attached to it you may be. If you don't put on tefillin for eight days, do you hold a ceremony to bid them farewell on Erev Pesach? When you finish a mitzvah, there are no goodbye ceremonies. So why, by the mitzvah of Sukkah, is there a whole יהי רצון and a ceremonious taking of leave — "until next year"? Why do we take leave of the Sukkah at all?

Rav Hutner explains: because the Sukkah is the Beis HaMikdash. One cannot simply walk out of the Beis HaMikdash. When you leave the Mikdash there is a mitzvah of linah, to remain overnight in Yerushalayim; you may not depart abruptly. Since the Sukkah possesses kedushas haMikdash, it too requires a special, ceremonious taking of leave.

This is the Yom Tov which is the happiest time of the year, because on it we achieve the greatest success a person can achieve: that Hashem wants us again.

Sources

  1. Devarim 16:2 וזבחת פסח לי-ה-ו-ה אלקיך צאן ובקר במקום אשר־יבחר י-ה-ו-ה לשכן שמו שם׃ ↩
  2. Devarim 16:13 חג הסכת תעשה לך שבעת ימים באספך מגרנך ומיקבך׃ ↩