Good for the Jews?? When Rosh Hashana Falls Out on Shabbos

Rosh Hashanah on Shabbos: Good for the Jews or Bad for the Jews?

The Shofar Is the Instrument

This year we have a phenomenon that is not unheard of but is certainly not common: Rosh Hashanah falling out on Shabbos. Sometimes eleven years go by without it, and then suddenly they come in clusters. Rosh Hashanah fell on Shabbos in 2023, the year of October 7th, and it falls on Shabbos again this year. What does it mean? What are the ramifications?

The Gemara in Rosh Hashanah on daf טז teaches a beraisa in the name of Rabbi Akiva. Why does the Torah say to bring the korban omer on Pesach? Because Pesach is the time of the grain harvest, and Hashem says: bring the omer so that your grain should be blessed. Why do we bring the shtei halechem on Shavuos? Because on Shavuos we are judged on the fruits of the tree, so Hashem says: bring the shtei halechem so that you will have a favorable judgment on the fruit. Why do we pour the water on Sukkos? Hashem says: pour the water before Me so that I will bless your water for the year. And along the same lines Hashem commands us on Rosh Hashanah to say מלכיות, זכרונות ושופרות. מלכיות — to coronate Hashem. זכרונות — so that your remembrance should rise before Me for the good. And with what does that remembrance rise? אמר רבי אבהו — with the shofar.1

That is the bottom line. You want a good year, you want a favorable judgment — the tool is the shofar. We coronate Hashem, we ask Him to remember us for the good, but the instrument that makes it happen is the shofar. The Gemara continues: why do we blow the shofar of a ram? Hashem says, blow before Me the shofar of a ram so that I will remember the Akeidas Yitzchak, and I will consider it as though you sacrificed yourselves before Me.

A little further on the daf the Gemara asks why we blow twice — תקיעות דמיושב before Shemoneh Esrei and תקיעות דמעומד during chazaras hashatz. The answer is כדי לערבב את השטן, to confuse the Satan. How exactly does that confuse him? Rashi explains that when the Satan sees how punctilious and particular we are with mitzvos, that we perform them and repeat them and are so careful about them, he is silenced. Rav Akiva Eger explains it differently. The Satan wants nothing more than to read off the laundry list of our sins. But when he sees how much we love mitzvos, that we do them again and again, he becomes worried that perhaps our teshuvah is תשובה מאהבה — and if we do teshuvah out of love, all of our aveiros are transformed into mitzvos. He is afraid to open the file, because instead of reading an account of sins he will end up reading an account of mitzvos. Tosafos gives the famous explanation: when the Satan hears the first blast he says, what was that, is that Mashiach? No, it can't be, it's only Rosh Hashanah. Then he hears the second set and says, that must be Mashiach, I'm out of a job — and he flees.

Either way, by blowing twice we silence the Satan. And do not fool yourself into thinking that if you got into the ring with the Satan you would hold your own. If Hashem does not help us, we are dead meat. We need every weapon in our arsenal, and the shofar is a mighty weapon indeed.

No Excuses

The Gemara continues with a statement of Rabbi Yitzchak: כל שנה שאין תוקעין לה בתחילתה מריעין לה בסופה — any year in which the shofar is not sounded at its beginning, evil befalls it at its end.2 Why? Because the Satan was not confused. Do not comfort yourself with "at least I learned Torah," or "at least I gave tzedakah." The Gemara says that any year the shofar is not blown, we are toast, because the Satan was not confused.

Comes Tosafos and asks: what if the reason the person did not blow was an אונס? What if he is locked up in Mother Russia and there is no shofar to be had? Is he toast? Yes. What if he is ill, cannot leave his bed, and cannot hear the shofar? Yes. Tosafos quotes the Bahag, the Halachos Gedolos, that even if the reason you did not blow was an אונס, it will still be a bad year at its end. Picture it: they get up to blow and the ceiling tile crashes down on the shofar and cracks it, and there isn't another shofar within the תחום. Nobody's fault. Nice boy, good boy — and a bad year.

Rav Aharon Kotler asks the obvious question. Is there not a fundamental rule of אונס רחמנא פטריה? A person who could not put on tefillin one day because he was ill and doubled over — is he punished? Of course not. Hashem is not here to bust anybody's chops. Furthermore, the Gemara in Berachos teaches that if a person intended to perform a mitzvah and circumstances beyond his control prevented him, it is accounted to him as though he performed it. So what could Tosafos possibly mean? Why should an אונס not be excused? That is the question of Rav Aharon in the Mishnas Rav Aharon.

And Rav Aharon answers: it must be that although every other mitzvah in the Torah is governed by אונס רחמנא פטריה, the shofar is different — because the shofar is not merely a mitzvah, it is an instrument. It is the mechanism by which our remembrance rises before Hashem for the good. If you don't have the instrument, your remembrance does not rise. It is like a man who wants cereal and the store is out of milk. It is not his fault. He is a fine, upstanding fellow. But guess what he doesn't have? Milk. "But it's not my fault!" Nobody is blaming you — you're just going to eat your Cheerios dry.

The Meshech Chochmah, Rav Meir Simcha of Dvinsk, frames it the same way. A man has strep and needs antibiotics, but the pharmaceutical companies aren't producing it and he can't get it. So he isn't going to get better. "But why? I didn't do anything wrong!" You didn't do anything wrong, and you're still not going to get better, because you don't have the medicine. Nobody is blaming you. It is simply reality. The shofar is the medication that fights the Satan, and if you don't have the medication, there is no way out. There are no excuses.

Except on Shabbos

But then Tosafos adds a crucial qualification: not if Rosh Hashanah falls out on Shabbos. If it falls on Shabbos, you will not have a bad year.

And that is the million-dollar question. If the man sick in bed is guaranteed a bad year — he asks the Rav, may I go to shul? The Rav says no. But Rebbi, will I have a bad year? Yes, you will have a bad year. So may I go? No. So I will have a bad year? Yes. If that is the reality, if the absence of the medication dooms the year no matter the reason, what difference does it make whether the reason is illness or Shabbos?

First we have to understand why we don't blow on Shabbos at all. This is a machlokes between the Yerushalmi and the Bavli. The Yerushalmi holds that it is מדאורייתא — זכרון תרועה, on Shabbos it is only remembered and not sounded. The Bavli holds otherwise: אמר רבא, מדאורייתא מישרא שרי, ורבנן הוא דגזור ביה, כדרבה. And Rabbah's reason is: הכל חייבין בתקיעת שופר ואין הכל בקיאין בתקיעת שופר, גזירה שמא יטלנו בידו וילך אצל הבקי ללמוד ויעבירנו ד' אמות ברשות הרבים. Everyone is obligated in shofar and not everyone is expert, so we are afraid a person will take it in his hand and carry it to an expert and transport it four amos in a public domain. It is a gezeirah d'rabanan.

And how old is this gezeirah? Rabbi Yosef Engel says: don't think Rava invented it. Rava merely taught it. The gezeirah was already in place from the day Moshe Rabbeinu came down from Har Sinai. From year one of the Torah there was an issur d'rabanan to blow shofar on Shabbos.

The Enormity of the Question

Now think about what we are saying. The shofar is medication. If you don't take it — allergic, unavailable, whatever the reason — you have a lousy year. And the rabbis came along and said: no, don't blow it, because you might carry four amos in a reshus harabim. How could they do that? They are jeopardizing the entire future of the year. They are playing with fire.

A man with a 104 fever who could not get to shul is guaranteed a bad year, and the rabbis are telling a whole nation, don't come, don't blow. Who would even listen? Who would even ask the shailah? There are three guarantees in this world: taxes, death, and a bad year for whoever misses the shofar.

Rav Aharon Kotler sharpens the difficulty. If a man were to carry that shofar four amos in the reshus harabim, would he even be violating Shabbos? He would not — because he is in the middle of performing a mitzvah, עוסק בדבר מצוה. The Mishnah in Sukkah teaches that one who forgot and carried his lulav out to shul because he was caught up in the mitzvah is not liable. So for a fear that a man might carry the shofar, and even if he did he would not be transgressing an issur d'oraisa, the Chachamim abandoned the mitzvah of shofar and put the entire destiny of Klal Yisrael in peril? Is this a good idea?

And there is an epic Tosafos that makes it worse. Why does the Gemara phrase the concern as carrying four amos within the reshus harabim? There are two forms of carrying: הוצאה, transferring between domains, and העברה, moving an object four amos within the public domain. Why didn't the Gemara simply say we are afraid he will carry it out of his house into the street? Because nobody would ever make that mistake. A person knows perfectly well: this is my house, that is the street. The only realistic worry is that a person will find a shofar lying in the reshus harabim and pick it up and carry it.

Now, I am not so old, but I wasn't born yesterday. I have never found a shofar in the reshus harabim. Have you? I have never met anyone who found a shofar in the street. I have never met anyone who knows someone who found a shofar in the street. And for that remote chashash, and for a chashash that even if realized would be at most a d'rabanan, they forfeited the entire destiny of the Jewish people?

It gets better. You would have to find that shofar in a genuine reshus harabim. There is a machlokes Rishonim what qualifies. Some Rishonim hold that a street sixteen amos wide suffices — and by that standard there could be no eruv in the Five Towns, no eruv in Queens, no eruv anywhere. That is why the Biur Halachah writes that a בעל נפש should be stringent. But we do not pasken that way. We pasken that a reshus harabim requires six hundred thousand people passing through. Are you familiar with any place in the world that is an actual reshus harabim? There are none in the Five Towns, none in Queens, virtually none anywhere in the world. The Chofetz Chaim writes in the Biur Halachah that it is almost impossible to have one. The only reshus harabim I know of is Ocean Parkway, where I grew up — I'll tell you a secret, Ocean Parkway — and we went outside on Shabbos, and chas v'shalom we did not rely on the eruv. So it is the one reshus harabim in the world. And I never found a shofar there either. I have found interesting things in my life. Never a shofar.

So the question of the Mishnas Rav Aharon, and of many of the Acharonim, stands in full force. The one mitzvah upon which the entire year depends, suspended over a worry that never materializes and would not even be a d'oraisa if it did. How do we understand it?

The First Approach: Yoma Arichta

The Tzitz Eliezer, Rav Eliezer Waldenberg, Chelek 17 Siman 77, answers that the rabbis who created the problem solved it before it ever began. Do we blow the shofar this year? Yes — on the second day.

And the second day of Rosh Hashanah is not like the second day of any other Yom Tov, because Rosh Hashanah is יומא אריכתא, one long day. The Baal Shem Tov gives the lomdus of why this is so: the first day of Adam HaRishon's creation was Erev Shabbos, Rosh Hashanah, and then came Shabbos — and it was thirty-six consecutive hours of sunlight; the sun did not set. From the very beginning of creation the two days functioned as one long day. The Chida brings another explanation, that the ten days of teshuvah correspond to the Aseres HaDibros, and אנכי and לא יהיה were said in a single utterance.

Either way, there is an established concept that the first two days of Rosh Hashanah are one day. So the Chachamim who suspended the blowing on the first day did not leave us empty-handed; they had already appended a second time period to it. If you blow on the second day, you have blown on Rosh Hashanah, and you have not violated כל שנה שאין תוקעין לה בתחילתה, because you did blow at the beginning of the year.

One might object: after all, the Chachamim could simply have adjusted the calendar so that Rosh Hashanah would never fall on Shabbos. Rosh Hashanah does not fall on Sunday and it does not fall on Friday — so make it not fall on Shabbos either. They did not want to do that. They preferred this arrangement, where the second day carries the first.

The Second Approach: The Akeidah of Shabbos

The Meshech Chochmah — this is now his hundredth yahrtzeit — offers a breathtaking answer. Why do we blow the shofar? To bring the Akeidas Yitzchak, performed with the shofar of a ram, before the Ribono Shel Olam. It is a commemoration of the Akeidah, and that is our greatest advocacy.

Says Rav Meir Simcha: Klal Yisrael and Hakadosh Baruch Hu are like two loyal friends and lovers, each concerned only for the welfare of the other. We declare שמע ישראל ה' אלוקינו ה' אחד — hear, Yisrael, there is one G-d. And Hashem responds with His own declaration, מי כעמך ישראל גוי אחד בארץ. Rav Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev observes the same pattern with Pesach: we call it חג הפסח, because G-d passed over our houses; Hashem calls it חג המצות, because you followed Me out of Mitzrayim without even time for your dough to rise. We are always concerned for His honor and He is always concerned for ours.

So Hashem writes in the Torah: blow the shofar, you need a good year. Hashem does not say "except when it comes out on Shabbos." We say it. We say: Ribono Shel Olam, if we blow the shofar on Shabbos, heaven forbid someone may come to carry. And if Shabbos is desecrated, who will testify that You created the world? Shabbos is the authentication of creation. Who will bear witness to the creation of heaven and earth?

And so we say: we know that for our own benefit You commanded us to blow, and we, for Your benefit, are prepared to make the ultimate sacrifice. We are willing to jeopardize our entire year, our entire future, so that the testimony of Shabbos not be compromised. There is no greater Akeidah that Klal Yisrael performs than putting our whole year in peril to preserve the sanctity of Shabbos. יתגדל ויתקדש שמיה רבא — let His Name be magnified and sanctified, come what may. We do not care what the end of the year will bring; we will sacrifice our existence rather than damage the testimony of Shabbos. That is a greater Akeidah than the Akeidas Yitzchak itself. And if so, why would we need to blow a shofar to remind Hashem of the Akeidah? We have produced our own Akeidah. That is how the Chachamim were able to suspend the tekiah when Rosh Hashanah falls on Shabbos.

The Third Approach: Yitzchak's Submission to the Chachamim

The Avnei Nezer, in his sefer on Chumash, offers something similar in spirit but sharper in its point.

Picture Yitzchak as a boy coming home from cheder. A friend asks, what's that you're putting on — tzitzis? Yes, my father says Hashem wants us to wear tzitzis. Where is that written? Did He give it to you at Sinai? No, no — my father, through his own understanding, figured out what Hashem wants. And what is this you're wrapping on your arm? Tefillin. My father knows everything Hashem wants. And Friday night, that cup of wine? Kiddush. We keep six hundred and thirteen mitzvos. And the friend asks: tell me, Yitzchak, is your father ever going to sacrifice you and kill you? Ridiculous, says Yitzchak. My father knows that Hashem detests human sacrifice. That is precisely what he spends his entire day teaching the world.

A few days later Avraham says, Yitzchak, may I have a word with you. We're going on a trip to Har HaMoriah. What are we doing there? Stay tuned. And a little later Avraham informs him: I have to be shochet you.

What should Yitzchak have said? For thirty-seven years you have been telling me Hashem despises human sacrifice! By rights he could have taken a brick to his father — Avraham is a רודף, he is trying to kill him. And what did Yitzchak do? Yitzchak said: even though according to everything I have learned I have no understanding of what Papa is doing, there is a principle in the Torah that once a person is established among the Chachmei Yisrael, if an authorized rabbinic figure instructs you to do something that appears bizarre in your eyes, you have אמונת חכמים. You trust the Chachamim, even when it seems מוזר מאד. חביבין דברי סופרים יותר מיינה של תורה — sometimes fulfilling what the Chachamim have commanded is more precious before Hashem than the Torah's own commands. People like to say, "but this is a d'oraisa, a d'oraisa is more important." Not necessarily. Yitzchak did not ask, did not question, did not so much as hesitate. He abdicated his own judgment and was מכניע to the Chachmei Yisrael.

And what are we doing on Rosh Hashanah that falls on Shabbos? The rabbis come and tell us to do something that to our eyes looks downright bizarre. The one instrument that secures a good year — and they say no, you must understand what could happen; you might find a shofar on Ocean Parkway and somebody might carry it four amos. We could argue, we could challenge, we could say that to our understanding this is not logical and not reasonable. And we don't. We submit.

That, says the Avnei Nezer, is exactly what Chazal engineered. In such a year we do not need to remind Hashem about the Akeidah, because the year itself is a precise parallel to the Akeidah. Just as Avraham told Yitzchak to do something seemingly bizarre that would forfeit his entire future, and Yitzchak was מכניע to the daas of the Chachmei Yisrael, so too we come to shul on such a Rosh Hashanah not to remember the Akeidah but to perform one — sacrificing our own judgment and deferring to the judgment of the Chachmei Yisrael, even when it seems to place us in peril.

The Fourth Approach: Chibuv Mitzvah in the Passive

Rav Aharon Kotler himself offers an answer. Why do we blow the shofar? To confuse the Satan. And how does that work? Because the Satan sees how dear mitzvos are to us — we do not suffice with one set of blasts, we blow a second set. It is the same idea the Gemara expresses in explaining why Hashem shows favoritism to Klal Yisrael: He wrote in the Torah that one bentches after eating enough to be satisfied, and we bentch over a kezayis.

So the operative principle is that when we display our love for mitzvos, the Satan is silenced. But is proactive performance the only way to display love for mitzvos? What about scrupulous carefulness not to come, heaven forbid, to violate a mitzvah? That too is chibuv hamitzvah — expressed passively, בשב ואל תעשה.

When the Satan sees how much we love and cherish the Shabbos, that we are prepared to forgo the shofar out of concern that someone might find one on Ocean Parkway and carry it — and I would wager that nobody in the history of the world ever found a shofar on Ocean Parkway — when the Satan sees that carefulness, that concern to safeguard the Shabbos, that is a level of chibuv hamitzvah that fully parallels what is accomplished by blowing the shofar twice. The Satan is silenced either way.

The Fifth Approach: Shabbos, Esquire

There is a fifth approach, very well known, and you are certainly going to hear it this year. It is worth remembering, and you will see why.

Now that we have established that a year without shofar is doomed unless the reason is Shabbos, the question presents itself: is it a good thing when Rosh Hashanah falls on Shabbos, or a bad thing? Good for the Jews or bad for the Jews?

Rabbi Yaakov Ettlinger, the Aruch LaNer, was a towering Talmudist — his chiddushim on Shas are so significant that Rabbi Akiva Eger wrote notes on them — and he was a great mekubal, and broadly learned besides. He would rise at עלות השחר and learn in tallis and tefillin until חצות, every single day. In his sefer on Chumash, Minchas Ani, he observes that the worst years in our history were years when Rosh Hashanah fell on Shabbos — and the best years in our history were likewise years when Rosh Hashanah fell on Shabbos. The year the first Beis HaMikdash was destroyed, Rosh Hashanah fell on Shabbos. The year the second Beis HaMikdash was destroyed, Rosh Hashanah fell on Shabbos. On the other hand, the year Hashem forgave us for the eigel, Rosh Hashanah fell on Shabbos. The year the Mishkan was erected, Rosh Hashanah fell on Shabbos. The year we entered Eretz Yisrael, Rosh Hashanah fell on Shabbos. It was the best of times and it was the worst of times. And by the way — October 7th, Rosh Hashanah fell on Shabbos.

Why? Why can't such a year simply be an ordinary year? Why must we be on edge for twelve months?

The mashal is this. A governor committed a crime, and the king was so incensed that he instructed the judges to give him no quarter. The governor needed an attorney, but firm after firm turned him down; everyone knew the king was set against him. He came home distraught and told his wife. She said: you know how much I love you. I will be your advocate. The king has a soft spot for me. She walked into the palace and pleaded his case, and she succeeded — because although the king would not hear a word from any defense attorney in the kingdom, for her he had a soft spot.

Some time later a different governor angered the king, and the story replayed itself. No attorney would touch it, and the man's poor wife offered to go. The problem was that this fellow was a rotten husband. He beat her, he struck her, and the evidence of his abuse was plain on her face and on her arms. Still she was loyal and obedient, and she came into the palace and began to speak sweetly to the king. And the king interrupted: what are these gashes and wounds on your face and on your arms? She stammered. She stuttered. She said she had tripped, she had fallen. And every judge in the room pointed at the husband — she did not trip, she did not fall. He beats her. A few hours later he was hanging, because his defense attorney had turned into his prosecutor.

Says the Aruch LaNer: we have a very fine attorney. His name is Shofar — Shofar and Shofar, LLC. They have tried hundreds of cases over the centuries with a brilliant record; no matter how badly the odds are stacked against you, Shofar and Shofar can bail you out. The trouble is that some years they cannot take the case. When Rosh Hashanah falls on Shabbos, we are up the creek without a paddle. What do we do? Worry not. Your dear loving wife can always bail you out.

Who is the wife of Klal Yisrael? Shabbos is the בן זוג of Klal Yisrael — Sunday has Monday, Tuesday has Wednesday, Thursday has Friday, and Shabbos has Yisrael. Your honey will walk into the palace and sweet-talk the King, and she is in a sense in cahoots with the King as well, for Shabbos is also His. She is a better advocate even than Shofar and Shofar, Inc.

But you had better make sure you treat her well. You have to make sure Shabbos comes in looking good — no wounds, no scars, no signs of abuse. If there is spousal abuse visible on the Shabbos, watch out. That is why 2023 was such a frightening year: the sole advocacy that year was Shabbos. Imagine what chillul Shabbos could do in a year like that.

And therefore the fate of a year in which Rosh Hashanah falls on Shabbos hinges on exactly one thing: how do we treat the Shabbos? Are we ready for her early? Do we honor her by escorting her out late? Are we wining and dining her properly? Are we even shomer Shabbos in the first place?

What It Means to Be Shomer Shabbos

Let me ask you something. If a man sleeps through the entire Shabbos, is he shomer Shabbos? I don't know. What does it actually mean to be shomer Shabbos?

Shabbos carries two meanings. Shabbos means cessation from melachah. But Shabbos also means שבתי בבית ה' — the Kesav veHakabala explains that the word connotes sitting, dwelling, reflecting, studying. The primary purpose of Shabbos is to have extra time for reflection, for study, for thinking about Hashem. If a person merely rests and does not devote significant time to Torah, that is not what being shomer Shabbos means.

So consider: I spend my Shabbos working through Mishpacha, Ami, Zman, the FJJ, the Yated, the Jewish Press, the Jewish Week, the Jewish Chronicle — all of these very holy and sanctified publications, none of which have the slightest thing to do with Shabbos. Shabbos is reserved for spiritual pursuit.

You have to spend time with your wife — and not doing what you feel like doing. Come, let's spend some quality time together watching the NFL? She is not interested in the NFL. She will let you know what she wants. Treat her well, and you will never have a year like it. Honor the Shabbos in a year like this and it could be the best year of your life. It all depends on the advocacy of Shabbos.

So how could the Chachamim suspend the shofar, our defense tool, when everything is on the line? Because the rabbis knew that as impressive as the shofar's record is, Shabbos and Shabbos, LLC is an even better defense team. But you must treat her well. Treat her well, and may this year be like the year Klal Yisrael entered Eretz Yisrael — a year of פדות and זכות for all of us.

Sources

  1. Rosh Hashanah 16a ↩
  2. Rosh Hashanah 16b ↩