When Rosh Hashanah Falls on Shabbat: Should We Be Concerned?
The Question That Was Handed to Me
A question was put before me: what happens when Rosh Hashanah falls out on Shabbat — should we be concerned? Honestly, I had never given the matter much thought before, and hearing it phrased that way made me a little nervous myself. What does he know that I don't know? Rosh Hashanah is Rosh Hashanah; you should be concerned every year. But once the question was planted in my head, I could not let it go, and I spent a full week researching it. The conclusion I reached is that this is a very, very important topic that deserves serious analysis, and I want to lay it out step by step and arrive at the proper conclusions.
We begin, as always, with the Gemara in Rosh Hashanah, which asks a disarming question: why do we blow the shofar? And the first answer is the one I love best — because Hashem said to blow the shofar. When it comes to mitzvot, you do not always need reasons. If God tells you to do something, you do it. When I was a boy and my mother told me to go to my room, I asked why, and she said, because I said so. A mother does not owe a child an explanation. Certainly God does not owe us one.
I remember in high school our rabbi asked the class why we sit in the sukkah on Sukkot, and everyone offered his theories. There was a boy from Aleppo, Shlomo Antebi — today a big chazan — and the Jews of Aleppo are obedient people who do not go hunting for reasons. He did not even speak English yet; they had to explain the question to him in Arabic. He looked at the rabbi cross-eyed. What do you mean, why? That's the law. Why are you wasting all these children's time with philosophy? That is the Gemara's first answer as well: that's the law, you blow the shofar.
The Courtroom and the Confusing of the Satan
The Gemara then presses further. Fine, but why the whole choreography — we blow sitting, then standing, then sitting again. What is all this up and down? To that the Gemara answers: כדי לערבב את השטן, in order to confuse the Satan.1
Understand what Rosh Hashanah is. It is a court case. God is the judge, and we are the defendants standing trial. The astonishing thing about this case is that millions of Jews are on trial at the same moment — it is a collective judgment, and yet the Borei Olam has every single file of every single person open before Him, and judges each one individually. It is a serious thing.
If you have ever been in a courtroom, you know that the great antagonist is the prosecutor. The prosecutor in Heaven is a very successful lawyer, and his name is Satan. He has been prosecuting our people since day one, and he walks into that courtroom on Rosh Hashanah with plenty to say. God calls order in the court and invites the prosecution to begin. And suddenly he hears the shofar. The congregation is sitting, then standing, then sitting again. And he becomes flustered — מסתתמין דבריו — he cannot get a word out of his mouth. God turns to him: do you have anything to say? No, no, forget it, I rest my case. And the Jewish people walk out exonerated.
How does the mechanism actually work? When we blow the shofar, God looks at His people and says, I told them to blow and they are obedient, they are compliant. And in any courtroom, the moment the prosecutor sees the judge looking at the defendant with warm eyes, he panics. Wait a minute — they are in cahoots. Why is the judge showing favoritism? The verdict must already be decided before I opened my mouth. So he loses his tongue, he becomes מעורבב, and he walks out of the courtroom. Everybody lives happily ever after. The shofar is the key element of the entire service.
A Year Without Shofar
The Gemara continues with a statement of Rabbi Yitzchak: any year in which they do not blow the shofar at its beginning, at its end they will blow it — because the Satan was not confused.2 Now, what does that mean? We only blow shofar on Rosh Hashanah. If you missed it, you missed it. But in earlier generations, when tragedy struck a community, one of the procedures was to take out the shofar and blow. Whenever you hear a shofar in the middle of the year, it is a sign that something went wrong. Even today, God forbid, at the end of a funeral, the custom is that the rabbi or one of the congregants takes a shofar and blows — a signal of tragedy, an alarm to do teshuvah.
So the Gemara is telling us something chilling: if you do not blow the shofar at the beginning of the year, rest assured there will be shofar later — not the shofar of Rosh Hashanah, but the shofar of tragedy. And the reason is exactly what we said. There was no shofar, the Satan was never confused, he prosecuted freely without apprehension or fear. And a year in which the Satan prosecutes freely is a year we should be concerned about.
So now we have two pieces of the formula. The shofar is the kryptonite of Rosh Hashanah — it is the one item that keeps the Satan at bay. And if for any reason we do not blow it, the congregation has cause for real concern, because that is a harbinger for the coming year.
Two Talmuds, Two Approaches
The Yerushalmi takes up a contradiction between two pesukim. Rosh Hashanah appears in two parashiot, in Emor and in Pinchas. In Emor the Torah calls it זכרון תרועה, a day when we remember the shofar blast.3 In Pinchas it calls it יום תרועה, a day of blowing.4 So which is it? Make up your mind — is it a day of remembering the shofar or a day of blowing the shofar?
The Yerushalmi gives a classic rabbinic answer: it depends. I will give you a piece of advice tonight — anytime someone asks you a question in rabbinic law, answer "it depends," and you will always be right. And if you want to be considered a real gadol, wave your hand a little while you say it. Everyone will say, what a Gaon. Because everything depends on everything.
What does it depend on? Which day of the week Rosh Hashanah falls out on. We know from the calendar that Rosh Hashanah cannot fall on Sunday, Wednesday, or Friday — לא אד"ו ראש. So it can fall on Monday, on Tuesday, on Thursday, or on Shabbat. Says the Yerushalmi: if Rosh Hashanah falls on a weekday, it is יום תרועה and we blow. But when Rosh Hashanah falls on Shabbat, it is not יום תרועה at all — it is זכרון תרועה. That is mind-boggling. According to the Yerushalmi, the absence of shofar on Shabbat is not a rabbinic decree at all; it is the Torah itself telling us that sometimes I want you to blow and sometimes I want you only to remember.
But what most of you have heard is the approach of the Bavli, and the Rambam in the Laws of Rosh Hashanah follows the Bavli, so we will take that as primary. There, Rosh Hashanah on Shabbat should by rights be a day of blowing — it is Rosh Hashanah, and Hashem said to blow. But Rava raises a concern: perhaps a person will take the shofar in hand and carry it four amot in the public domain, and violate Shabbat.5 Therefore the shofar is taken away from everybody.
Risk and Reward
Now let me speak plainly. I am all for protecting Shabbat. I am all for making sure nobody carries in the public domain. Do not misunderstand me. But guess what — I am also very much in favor of confusing the Satan on Rosh Hashanah. And the Gemara itself told us that the only way to do that is with a shofar.
So I introduce a simple formula that I apply to every decision in life: risk and reward. Weigh the risk against the reward, and ask whether the risk is significant enough to deny ourselves the potential gain. Here I think it is a no-brainer. Yes, there is a risk that somebody might carry the shofar. But to me it is remote in the extreme. In over fifty years I have never seen anybody carry a shofar — not on Shabbat, not on a weekday. It sits on the tevah. It grows on the tevah. It somehow generates organically on the tevah. And who is blowing the shofar? Usually the rabbi, the most religious man in the congregation. He is going to forget that it is Shabbat? If he forgets that Rosh Hashanah is Shabbat, he has no business blowing the shofar in the first place.
But fine — let us grant a one percent chance, and I think I am being generous. On that logic, let me legislate something new: let us cancel brit milah on Shabbat, which is far more common. Every week there is a brit on Shabbat, and the mohel might carry the knife or carry the baby. We do not say that. Only with shofar, which comes once a year, and where an announcement can simply be made to bring it to shul before Shabbat.
And on the other side of the scale? כדי לערבב את השטן. I put them both on the scale — a one percent chance that in a million years will never happen, against the confusion of the Satan. And I say to myself, why are the rabbis doing this to us? It is like a drowning man wearing a life jacket, and the rabbis come along and say, give us the life jacket — and then stand and watch him drown, God forbid.
One of the women in Deal asked me a beautiful question. We have a rule that when a life is in danger we override Shabbat, and a person who does melachah to save a life is doing a mitzvah. Our lives are in danger on Rosh Hashanah — we are literally on trial for life and death. So why not push aside Shabbat here? Even if somebody might carry, are we going to jeopardize the entire Jewish people over a gezeirah we do not even understand? But that is what it is. And so, in a year when Rosh Hashanah falls on Shabbat, it appears at first glance that the rabbis have taken away our single greatest defense mechanism against the Satan.
The Testimony of History
There was a great rabbi from Germany, Rabbi Yaakov Ettlinger, alav hashalom — the rabbi of Rav Samson Raphael Hirsch, a Gaon who wrote on the Talmud in Aruch LaNer and also published his derashot in a sefer called Minchat Ani. In his derashah on Parashat Haazinu he says something stunning. He researched this very question of Rosh Hashanah falling on Shabbat, and his conclusion was that such a year is always an extreme year. Sometimes extremely bad, and sometimes extremely good.
And he lists them. The year the First Temple was destroyed, Rosh Hashanah fell on Shabbat. The year the Second Temple was destroyed, Rosh Hashanah fell on Shabbat. The year of the Inquisition. The year Hitler was appointed Chancellor. A long list of terrible things.
But then he turns the page. The year the Jewish people were forgiven for the sin of the golden calf — Rosh Hashanah fell on Shabbat. The year the Mishkan was built — Rosh Hashanah fell on Shabbat. The year Yehoshua brought the Jewish people into the Land of Israel — Rosh Hashanah fell on Shabbat. So now the matter becomes genuinely confusing. There is no shofar either way. Why should the same configuration produce catastrophe in one year and redemption in another? And why would the rabbis take this away from us at all? That is the question that requires an answer.
The First Answer: The Akeidah of Israel
The first answer belongs to the Meshech Chochmah, Rabbi Meir Simcha HaKohen of Dvinsk. It is not the answer I came to give, but it is famous and it deserves to be heard — it really deserves a shiur of its own.
He says that whenever God brings to mind the Akeidat Yitzchak, He is filled with an abundance of mercy and a desire to send bounty down to the Jewish people. Anytime He remembers it. That is why, whenever we are in trouble, we look for something that will remind God of the Akeidah. Once we have directed God's attention there, we know a berachah is coming down.
What was it about the Akeidah that draws such compassion? Two words: mesirut nefesh. Understand that both Avraham and Yitzchak made an absolute sacrifice, and neither of them knew it would be called off at the last moment. They fully expected to go through with it. Avraham was a hundred and thirty-seven years old, and this was his only son from Sarah. It was a double sacrifice: first to slaughter Yitzchak, and then to go home and explain to Sarah what he had done. And Avraham does not ask a single question. And Yitzchak tells his father: tie me down tightly, so that you do it properly.
The Zohar teaches that when a person surrenders his ratzon — his will, his desire — to God, it creates a pipe, a צינור, through which the Borei Olam sends down the greatest bounty imaginable. And צינור is the very same letters as רצון. The suppression of one's own will in favor of the will of Hashem opens a conduit — not a little pipe like the one under your sink, but a main line, and out of it pour the berachot. The Akeidah opened a main line, because it was genuine mesirut nefesh; they were prepared to die for God, which is the highest level there is.
See how great it was. When Avraham takes the knife, the pasuk calls it a מאכלת.6 We do not normally call a knife a מאכלת; that is a ten-dollar word. Ordinarily a knife is a סכין. Simply understood, מאכלת is the utensil that prepares food for eating. But our Chachamim taught: Avraham prepared with it a dish that we have been eating from for three and a half thousand years. He prepared an entrée. Three and a half millennia later we are still eating from the Akeidah, that pipe is still flowing, and so whenever we need something we immediately bring Hashem's mind back to it.
That is why the prayers in the morning truly begin fifteen minutes before most people arrive — with Akeidat Yitzchak. If you come to shul on time you start on page forty; if you come early you start from the beginning, and the beginning is the Akeidah, every single day, not only on the holidays. We always want to place it before Hashem, because He remembers it and the entrée is served. And that is why on Rosh Hashanah, immediately before we blow, we recite an entire poem to fix our minds on the Akeidah. Then we pick up the shofar — a ram's horn, because Avraham brought a ram in Yitzchak's place. The shofar is the prop that reminds God of the Akeidah.
So take this to heart: the next time you control yourself and suppress a desire, offer a prayer at that very moment, because there is a great flood of mercy in Heaven at that instant. There is nothing you can send upward more powerful than mesirut nefesh. You send it up, you break through, and the berachah comes down. I once said this to a class of men — that when you are walking in Manhattan and something inappropriate passes in front of you, if you close your eyes and do not look, that is a suppression of desire; make a prayer then and you will see results. Someone asked, guaranteed, Rabbi? I said guaranteed. The following week one of them came over: I did it, and it did not work. Tell me exactly what happened. I was walking down Fifth Avenue, something inappropriate came in front of me, I closed my eyes, I waited until it passed, and I made a tefillah. And then what? Then I turned around to look. Well, you threw away your mesirut nefesh.
Now here is the brilliance of the Meshech Chochmah. Suppose I could present to God on Rosh Hashanah a substitute sacrifice. I cannot deliver the Akeidah, because the shofar is what delivers it and there is no shofar. But suppose I could stand in that courtroom and say: they took away the shofar, and I would like to offer something else instead. If you can find a substitute, it accomplishes exactly what the shofar accomplishes.
So picture the scene. Rosh Hashanah on Shabbat, the Satan is about to speak, and God looks down and says, how come they are not blowing the shofar? Do they not know what happens to a year without shofar? And then He looks again and sees: they are not blowing in order to protect My Shabbat. They are doing it for Me. They are willing to forfeit their entire Rosh Hashanah, to forfeit the whole year, to let the Satan prosecute unopposed — so that My Shabbat should not be touched. That is not Akeidat Yitzchak; that is Akeidat Yisrael. God sees a whole nation, millions of people, saying: fine, it may not be a good year, kaparah, but Shabbat will be protected. And God says, I love this people. The Satan sputters — you still love them, they did not even blow the shofar! — מסתתמין דבריו, and he runs out of the courtroom.
So it turns out that the very absence of the shofar generates the identical mesirut nefesh that the Akeidah generates in a normal year. We lose nothing. By not blowing, we accomplish precisely what blowing would have accomplished.
The Second Answer: Emunat Chachamim
There is a second answer, from Rabbi Aryeh Tzvi Frommer in his responsa, and it too is important to know.
Let me preface it with a story. A few years ago in Deal, I was walking from Minchah to Seudah Shlishit — hundreds of people wash for bread and then come in for the derashah — together with one of the Gedolim from Jerusalem. I asked him, Rabbi, is this not impressive? All these people coming to learn in the summer, in a resort town. He said: I have been all over the world, to every community, and there is something genuinely unique about your community — something that I believe brings you berachah, not only parnasah but the unity, the infrastructure, the whole structure of it. I was glad to hear it, and I asked him: why? What is it that you think we are blessed for? He answered without hesitation: אמונת חכמים. Your community has extraordinary obedience, reverence, loyalty and respect for the Chachamim.
That was always the old Aleppo way. They believed in the Chachamim, they respected them, they loved them, and there was a camaraderie. Our salaries do not necessarily reflect that love, I will be honest with you, but the reverence is real. When I was young I was sideswiped by a car coming out of yeshiva; my glasses were knocked off my face and I was badly shaken up. What does a normal parent do? Runs to the doctor. My parents took me straight to Chacham Baruch's house. What is Chacham Baruch going to do? He is going to give a berachah — and then we go to the doctor. That is the old Syrian way. And Hashem loves emunat chachamim for a simple reason: the Chachamim are God's ambassadors. We cannot touch God; the Chachamim are His representatives on earth, and by honoring them we honor Him.
Now, the Chatam Sofer raises a philosophical question: who faced the greater test at the Akeidah, Avraham or Yitzchak? You already know my answer — it depends. I could argue it either way, and I think I could convince you either way. On Avraham's side: for a father to slaughter his son, and then to explain it to his wife; Yitzchak has nobody to explain it to. Avraham is the ish chesed, and this cuts directly against his grain. Avraham has an entire yeshiva that he has been teaching for years that cruelty is forbidden, and now he is going to be cruel and undo his life's work. It is an enormous challenge.
But the Chatam Sofer says that as hard as it was for Avraham, it was harder for Yitzchak. Let me ask you: if God appeared to you in a vision, and you had no doubt whatsoever that it was Hashem, and He told you to do something — however difficult — I have no doubt that every one of you would comply. וישכם אברהם בבוקר,7 and you would rise in the morning and do the will of God. Why? Because you heard it. Avraham heard it directly from the mouth of God.
Yitzchak heard nothing. Yitzchak heard it from his father — secondhand information. If I were Yitzchak I would say: my father is a hundred and thirty-seven years old; at that age one begins to forget things. And even out of loyalty I would say, Daddy, I have no doubt Hashem spoke to you, but I think you misheard Him. He meant Yishmael. And I will help you — I will even help you tie him down. Man walking around with a knife? I am calling social services. The fact that Yitzchak accepts what his father tells him — that is the point. Avraham was not only Yitzchak's father, he was Yitzchak's rabbi. This is the supreme example of emunat chachamim. The rabbi says, let us slaughter you, and Yitzchak acquiesces. Why is he so loyal? Because he knows that Avraham receives his instructions from God. Emunat chachamim is emunat Hashem. את ה' אלוקיך תירא — the word את comes to include the Chachamim.8 It is one and the same. And whenever God sees emunat chachamim, He rises from the throne of judgment and moves to the throne of mercy.
That is the greatness of the Akeidah, and that is why we always want to remind God of it: look at Yitzchak's loyalty, look at his obedience to his rabbi. And I am sorry to tell you that on a Rosh Hashanah without a shofar we do not have access to that event, because the shofar is what connects us to it. Take away the shofar and the connection is severed.
But, says Rabbi Frommer, if I could reproduce emunat chachamim from another direction, I would accomplish exactly what the Akeidah accomplishes. So back to the courtroom. Millions of people standing, every file open, and God says to the Satan: are you ready? And then — wait. How come they are not blowing the shofar today? He opens the Talmud Bavli and reads that the rabbis said not to blow, because of a remote worry that somewhere, somebody might carry. And God says: and they listened? They gave up the shofar because a rabbi said so, over something that far-fetched? Yes — all of them, every single one. And nobody had the nerve to say, we do not care what the rabbis say, we do not want to die. God says: I have never seen emunat chachamim like this. This is even greater than Akeidat Yitzchak — they are all prepared to go without their one defense because rabbis in the Talmud said not to blow, and the Rambam wrote it, and the Shulchan Aruch codified it, and they are listening to My representatives. And the Satan says: they got me again. I was trying to get away from the Akeidah and they beat me anyway. Do you have anything to say? He walks out flustered. Exonerated.
The Third Answer: The Ben Ish Chai's Secret
But the answer I really came to give is the third one, and it comes from the sefer Torah Lishmah — a fascinating work containing close to five hundred responsa. At the end of each teshuvah the author signs with a pen name, and for generations nobody knew who he was.
Years ago in Jerusalem I visited Rav Yaakov Hillel in his yeshiva, Ahavat Shalom, and I asked him whether he had any idea who this rabbi was. He said, I am positive I know. Who? The Ben Ish Chai. But his name is Yosef Chaim — yes, and he published this work anonymously under a pen name. How does the Rav know? He said, come. He took out a sheet of paper: this is an actual manuscript of the Ben Ish Chai's writings, in his own hand. Can I touch it? Yes. And here is the manuscript of Torah Lishmah — look at the handwriting; it is identical. There is no doubt they are the same author. I asked, does the Rav have many of these manuscripts? Yes. Could I have a small piece of that manuscript? Absolutely. Thank you very much. Five million dollars. I said, I will take a photocopy. And strangely enough, last year I officiated at a wedding for someone out of the community, and he wanted to give me something special. I told him I could supply a list, but he insisted on something meaningful — and he gave me an actual page of the Ben Ish Chai's manuscript. It hangs framed behind me in the shul in Brooklyn where I give the Daf Yomi.
In Torah Lishmah, in teshuvah 436, the Ben Ish Chai asks precisely our question.9 The Kabbalists teach that the shofar moves the entire world, that it rectifies and prepares everything — a million and one things that most people never knew the shofar accomplishes. So what are we to do on a Rosh Hashanah that falls on Shabbat, when we have none of it?
And hold on to your seats, because only the Ben Ish Chai can say this. He says: that reason the Gemara gave — that we might come to carry — is not the real reason. It is a smokescreen. Of course it sounds remote and of course it does not make sense; that is because it is not the actual reason. Then why did they say it? Because they needed something to tell the ordinary person. We are not going to deliver a whole derashah to every man who walks in. Rabbi, why are we not blowing the shofar this year? Because we are worried somebody might carry. Ah — makes sense. And he walks away satisfied, never realizing the answer does not hold up. You have to give a taam, a little reason, to pacify the amcha. But do not pay too much attention to it. The Chachamim had something else in their pocket.
Here is what they had in their pocket. They knew — with divine inspiration they knew — the truth: you do not need the shofar, because you have Shabbat. The tikkun of Shabbat accomplishes whatever the shofar accomplishes, and perhaps more. In fact it is the reverse of what you assumed: when Rosh Hashanah does not fall on Shabbat, then you need a shofar. When it does fall on Shabbat, what would you need the shofar for? If anything, picking up a shofar on such a day belittles Shabbat — you do not think Shabbat can handle it? Shabbat is very strong. Which means that the primary Rosh Hashanah is a Rosh Hashanah that falls on Shabbat.
Shabbat Is the Shofar
There was a great rabbi, the Admor of Slonim, who reads it out of the pasuk we say on the night of Rosh Hashanah: תקעו בחודש שופר בכסה ליום חגנו.10 תקעו — blow. בחודש — in the month. Which month? בכסה — the month in which the moon is covered. All of our festivals fall on the fifteenth, when the moon is full; Rosh Hashanah alone falls at the head of the month, when the moon is hidden. And which Rosh Hashanah is the one the pasuk calls ליום חגנו, our day of rejoicing? Take the first letters: תקעו — tav. בחודש — bet. שופר — shin. Read them backwards: שבת. That is the primary Rosh Hashanah. תקעו בחודש שופר — how? Through Shabbat. Shabbat is the shofar.
Let me explain why. When was Adam HaRishon born? On a Friday. If you look at his birth certificate it says born Friday; it says male — in those days you were still permitted to write male on a birth certificate; it does not list parents, because his parents were God; the place of birth is Gan Eden; and the date is the first of Tishrei. Adam HaRishon was born on Rosh Hashanah. That is his birthday. That is why the Torah opens with the word בראשית — when did the world truly begin? With Adam HaRishon. And בראשית contains the same letters as א' בתשרי. Chavah too was created that day.
And we know what happened. They ate from the tree they were told not to eat from. For the sake of accuracy, Chavah gave it to Adam — I am only stating the record, not assigning blame; in the end both of them ate. And God had said: on the day you eat, you shall die.
Now Shabbat entered. And the Midrash tells us something you have never heard elsewhere: the Borei Olam convened a beit din on Shabbat. There is the Judge, and there are the defendants, Adam and Chavah, and the Satan is present, having come as the snake. He testifies: they ate, I was there, I am a witness. Adam turns to him — you told me to eat. And the Satan answers: you should not have listened to me. God said no and I said yes; whom do you listen to, the student or the rabbi? And he pressed his prosecution. And this was Rosh Hashanah — that was the day it all happened.
God says: does anyone have anything to say? And in walks Shabbat. Yes, Shabbat — because Shabbat is a living being; do not let anyone tell you otherwise. The power of Shabbat entered the courtroom. Who are you? I am Shabbat. You just created me. And Shabbat says to God: in the six days in which You created the world You did not kill anyone. And now the first sentence of execution ever handed down in a beit din is going to fall on my day? Where is the kedushah? Where is the berachah of my day? It is not fair. And God said: you have just saved Adam HaRishon. I accept the claim. And Adam said, Shabbat, I cannot believe it — you saved my life; and he began to sing.
So Shabbat has been protecting us since the days of Adam HaRishon. And note well: there was no shofar in Adam's time either. How did he escape judgment? Shabbat walked in and defended him. This is not a new arrangement. Shabbat is a defense attorney, and it does its finest work specifically on Rosh Hashanah.
In an ordinary year, when Rosh Hashanah falls midweek, we have to go looking for an alternative — we take a shofar, we invoke the Akeidah, we construct a whole pilpul. But when Rosh Hashanah falls on Shabbat, we have the oldest and most seasoned defense lawyer in all of history, with a proven record in this exact courtroom. That is why the language is יום טוב של ראש השנה שחל להיות בשבת — it is a yom tov. It is a great day. Because we have the best lawyer, and we have precedent: he already defeated the Satan on this very day, close to fifty-eight centuries ago. Déjà vu — why should it not happen again?
Why Some Years Are Good and Some Are Not
But if that is so, we are back to Rabbi Ettlinger's problem. If Shabbat is the greatest of all defenders, why should some of these years turn out catastrophically? It should be extremely good every time.
He answers with a parable, and it is always good to end with a parable. A man committed a crime against the king and was sentenced to death by the guillotine. His wife had connections in the government, among the judges and ministers, so she asked her husband: give me permission to go and petition on your behalf. Of course, he said — save my life. She went to the king and to all the ministers and pleaded: I know my husband committed a crime, but we are married, we have children, we have a family; by and large he is a good man who made a mistake. She petitioned and petitioned until finally the king had mercy. Go tell your husband he is pardoned.
There was another man on death row who saw how easily it had worked. They are not going to say no to a lady. So he told his wife: go and petition for me. And she agreed. The only trouble was that she was an abused wife. Her husband beat her; she had a black eye and marks all over her face. But she was afraid of him, so she went. She came before the king and began, please, my husband — and the king stopped her. Your husband? Where did you get that black eye? What are all these bruises? She looked down. Do not tell me your husband did this to you. And the king began to weep. And he came to me for a pardon? You will never defend this man. The one who abuses you — you are going to defend him? You stay right here.
Says Rabbi Ettlinger: we are married to Shabbat. Shabbat is our spouse. Shabbat walks into the courtroom on Rosh Hashanah and defends the people who have treated it with respect. But God forbid Shabbat should walk in bruised and blemished. God says: who did that to you? And this man expects you to defend him after he was mechalel Shabbat, after he disregarded you and did not keep you? You will defend nobody.
Shabbat is a great protector, but it works in both directions. During the week we ask for שמירה; on Shabbat we do not say שומר, we say שלום — it is peace. If you are good to Shabbat, Hashem accepts Shabbat's defense. But if your Shabbat has been abused and mistreated, you have no chance on Rosh Hashanah. Hashem will not accept the defense, and then the Satan has plenty to say.
That, says Rabbi Ettlinger, is the difference between the good years and the terrible ones. On October seventh — and we do not like to say this too loudly — the fact was that the kibbutzim along the border which kept Shabbat were passed over. You have seen the videos. The Arabs reached the gates, turned around, and went next door. Nobody could understand it. There was no shofar that year. Shabbat came to court. Where Shabbat appeared as a beautiful bride in a white gown, God said: say whatever you like, we will protect your husband. Where she came in bruised, He said: you will defend nobody. There is no shofar, and Shabbat can do nothing.
So Should We Be Concerned?
So the question that was put to me is a good one, and the answer is yes — we should absolutely be concerned. But concerned about what? How was our Shabbat? That is what we should be concerned about. Is the lawyer going to defend us or not?
The good news is that there are still two Shabbatot before Rosh Hashanah, and you can make shalom bayit in two weeks. It does not take longer than that to reconcile with Shabbat. For shalom bayit you do not have to turn a hundred and eighty degrees; you have to show that you are willing, you have to take a step. So my recommendation for these coming weeks is to do something for Shabbat that you have never done before — whether in the realm of halacha, which is the main thing, or in the honor of Shabbat, or in how you dress for Shabbat. Something to show the lawyer. Say honestly: I am not perfect, I cannot learn all of Hilchot Shabbat in two weeks, that is impossible — but I am making an effort. And Shabbat answers: fine, that is enough for me. As long as I see you moving toward me, I will represent you. We are putting Shabbat on retainer. But you need a relationship with Shabbat in order to put it on retainer and have it represent you properly. This is the key.
I conclude with Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev, whose grave in Ukraine we have visited many times, in safer days. Once, on a Rosh Hashanah that fell on Shabbat, he turned to God and said: Master of the World, just as we keep Shabbat, You keep Shabbat. And it is forbidden to write on Shabbat. If we cannot write, You cannot write. Which means You cannot inscribe us in the book of death, and You cannot inscribe us in any of those terrible books, because writing is forbidden on Shabbat. But we also know the law that to save a life one may desecrate Shabbat. Therefore, to inscribe us in the book of life — that You are permitted to write. So on this Shabbat You may write us only in the book of life. Look at that melitz yosher. And all of it flows from the koach of Shabbat.
That is the great secret the Ben Ish Chai handed us. The Gemara told you we might come to carry — do not pay too much attention to it. When Rosh Hashanah falls on Shabbat, it is handled. It is on autopilot. Whatever you need happens through Shabbat itself.
So the short answer to the question: should we be concerned? It depends — we are back to that answer again. It depends on us. It depends on the state of our marriage with Shabbat. I said in Deal yesterday that it was perhaps the most beautiful day of the summer, and bli ayin hara there were hundreds of men and women at the shiur on Shabbat. Ten-thirty in the morning and everyone still in the synagogue, everyone dressed properly. Nobody on a tennis court, nobody at a swimming pool, nobody on a pickleball court. Regular people — pink shirts, blue shirts, plain amcha, a few black hats — sitting for an hour and a half listening to a derashah. I told them: you have no idea what you are doing here. Shabbat is present, watching. Shabbat is taking notes and writing down every name. This one is a shomer Shabbat. This one honors me. Look at this husband, honoring his spouse. You have nothing to worry about — on Rosh Hashanah, Shabbat will defend you.
And I say the same to this congregation. The fact that you came out on a Sunday night to hear words of Torah, to understand the mechanics of this — and what was our subject? The value of Shabbat. Shabbat is alive. Shabbat is here with us, and Shabbat says: in the merit that they spoke in my favor, that they came to my defense, that they had the mesirut nefesh to come to a shiur — I will represent you on Rosh Hashanah. And the Satan will shake his head and say: look at this, even without a shofar they got me again. So we need not worry too much. We have the ability to confuse the Satan even without the shofar, and it is called שמירת שבת.
Sources
- Rosh Hashanah 16b ↩
- Rosh Hashanah 16b ↩
- Vayikra 23:24 דבר אל־בני ישראל לאמר בחדש השביעי באחד לחדש יהיה לכם שבתון זכרון תרועה מקרא־קדש׃ ↩
- Bamidbar 29:1 ובחדש השביעי באחד לחדש מקרא־קדש יהיה לכם כל־מלאכת עבדה לא תעשו יום תרועה יהיה לכם׃ ↩
- Rosh Hashanah 29b ↩
- Bereshit 22:10 וישלח אברהם את־ידו ויקח את־המאכלת לשחט את־בנו׃ ↩
- Bereshit 22:3 וישכם אברהם בבקר ויחבש את־חמרו ויקח את־שני נעריו אתו ואת יצחק בנו ויבקע עצי עלה ויקם וילך אל־המקום אשר־אמר־לו האלקים׃ ↩
- Pesachim 22b ↩
- Torah Lishmah 436 not in Sefaria תשובה בענין ראש השנה שחל להיות בשבת שאין תוקעין בשופר ↩
- Tehillim 81:4 תקעו בחדש שופר בכסה ליום חגנו׃ ↩
